Inventory valuation plays a significant role in reporting operating results, as well as the
state of affairs of a business entity, because it serves period accounting and happens to
be the largest single line item in non-manufacturing firms and public utilities, and
the second largest item in many manufacturing firms. Inconsistent and selective
valuation methods would result in inaccurate and inconsistent financial results.
Empirical literature suggests that inventory valuation is one of the devices often
resorted to smooth out a firm’s operating results. The study aims to find out the
prevailing practices, diversity in such practices, degree of adherence to mandatory
behavioral prescriptions of the Accounting Standard and possible reasons for a
substance-wise departure from such stipulations. The study is aimed at aiding
policymakers to come out with modified behavioral prescriptions as far as futuristic
compliance is concerned. The findings suggest that the disclosure of accounting policies
regarding inventory valuation in listed Indian companies is more of a form than of
substance, and there is ample scope for improvement in fixing the valuation norms.
The importance of disclosing significant accounting policies and related notes on accounts
thereon constitute one significant aspect of the overall accounting disclosure.
Carolyn A Streuly made a survey among the Chartered Financial Analysts in the USA, the
prime users of annual reports of companies, for ascertaining whether the primary objectives of
financial reporting are being met or not. The specific questions that were addressed in this
study are: Are there too many disclosures in the annual reports? Should more be added? Are
the financial statements and notes useful to financial statement users? Should some items be
removed? The result suggested that the primary objective of financial reporting is being met
because: 1) The majority of respondents report that the information disclosed in the annual
reports is adequate for investment decisions; 2) The primary financial statements range from
being very useful to extremely useful to CFAs, on average in investment decisions; 3) The
average usefulness of the notes, as a whole, to CFAs in investment decisions falls in the range
of being average useful to very useful; 4) The vast majority of individual financial statement
line items and notes examined are, on an average, more than moderately useful to CFAs in
investment decisions. |