For too long now Frantz Fanon, psychiatrist, activist, anti-colonial
fighter, decorated war hero and arguably the first major postcolonial `theorist' of
the twentieth century, has been seen exclusively as an apostle of violence. This
is partly because of the initial reception of Fanon's now-cult texts, Black Skin White Masks (BSWM), Towards an African Revolution (TAR), The Wretched of the
Earth (WE) and A Dying Colonialism (DC), by thinkers like Hannah
Arendtwho accused Fanon of `glorifying violence for violence's sake' (1970, 65).
Several thinkers since then (Bulhan, 1985; Taylor, 1992; Nandy, 1992;
and Serequeberhan, 1994) have grappled with what looks like an advocacy of
violence on the one hand and a deeply humanist thought on the other in Fanon's
writings. In this essay I propose that despite his insistence on violence, Fanon
engages with, and offers, a humanist vision.
First, a quick note on how one can read the violence in Fanon. Violence
in Fanon is directed at two specific goals. The first goal is the overthrow of
the colonizer. Fanon sees the violence of the native as a consequence of the
violence inherent in the colonial system itself. The violence is embedded in the
dialectic of master-slave, where the only means to attaining selfhood the
dehumanized slave has is violence because it is the only language of colonial relations. This
is the violence of the anti-colonial struggle during the course of which the
context for the second goal of this violence is also generated. This second goal is of
the colonized's self-realization and the retrieval of subjectivitya goal that
Fanon sees as possible only through violence. This retrieved subjectivity, dignity
and identity, for Fanon, quite possibly leads to death and annihilation. But
this annihilation would be one of choice and selfhood rather than abjection,
with Fanon arguing that he would be willing to accept `dissolution'
(BSWM, 170). It is in this second mode of violence as directed at self-realization that Fanon
finds the possibilities of a new identity and humanism. The `savage struggle'
through which the former slave claims recognition from the white is therefore the
`source material', so to speak, of a new black man. Violenceof the anti-colonial struggle and decolonizationtherefore, becomes the anterior moment of (i) a new subjectivity
and cultural identity; (ii) a new humanism. |