IUP Publications Online
Home About IUP Magazines Journals Books Archives
     
A Guided Tour | Recommend | Links | Subscriber Services | Feedback | Subscribe Online
 
The IUP Journal of American Literature
Illusion versus Reality in the Major Plays of Eugene O'Neill
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Illusion and reality are the two poles between which the action of most of the plays of Eugene O'Neill moves. In the twentieth century, science, industrialization, urbanization, and democratic idealism failed to restore the identity of man. Faced with the absurdity, nothingness, and meaninglessness of modern life, O'Neill's characters find themselves unable to establish a creative and spontaneous relationship with the world. These characters try to live up to false self-images and perpetuate illusory conception of their selves. This paper shows how O'Neill, in his plays, focuses his attention on man's endless struggle between illusion and reality, between the opposite images of the self. Meaningful action is possible only when man strips off his illusion fronting the shapeless and nameless terrors of existence and acts in obedience to the secret impulse of his character. Thus, finally, man experiences a rich and stupendous sense of mystery of life and universe, and survives.

 
 
 

Eugene O'Neill's major dramas are built on the pervasive theme of illusion versus reality, with variations here and there. O'Neill stresses, in his dramas, the necessity for individuals to have some illusions to live by, for, he thinks, mankind cannot bear too much of reality. His protagonists are often split personalities who wear masks, consume liquor, utter soliloquies, and are obsessed with the subconscious drivers and impulses that lead them to adopt tragic roles. They are mostly in search of their identity and are alternately tossed between illusion and reality, clinging sometimes to illusion, but ultimately forced to come to grips with reality. O'Neill shows us that the background of conflicting tides in the soul is more real, universal, and more decisive than the partial individuality of men and women. The conscious will plays very little part in their lives, and all their aspirations to belong to something nobler and higher prove ultimately illusory. The long gallery of portraits spells out O'Neill's own intellectual and spiritual biography at different stages of his life. Perhaps, it would not be an exaggeration to observe that O'Neill himself is the hero of his important dramas and that the problem of illusion and reality is, in fact, a manifestation of his own quest for identity and faith.

The essence of O'Neill's dramatic output is the grim futility of human existence, cursed by alienation from self, society, and the source-of-all-life, and made bearable only by illusion. The essential O'Neill's hero can be characterized as a rebel, a dreamer, an idealist, and an individualist, challenging established modes and living in an illusory world of his own. His protagonists' attitude towards life is sardonic, sneering, cynical, romantic, full of pride, and aloofness—in short, the epitome of the author's own self-portrait. They are preoccupied in a voyage to self-discovery and are seen engaged in a pursuit of meaning and significance in a world without God and religion. They range from `landlocked' Mayo (Beyond the Horizon), the tubercular press reporter Stephen Murrey (The Straw), semi-incestuous Eben Cabbot (Desire under the Elms), the possessive Michael Cape (Welded), the defeated idealist Dion Anthony (The Great God Brown), the suicidal Reuben Light (Dynamo), the rebellious adolescent Richard Miller (Ah, Wilderness!), the pipe dreamer Larry Slade (The Iceman Cometh), and finally the spokesman of the fog people Edmund Tyrone (Long Day's Journey into Night). Their restless quest for new absolutes arises from perpetual dissatisfaction with material and commercial values. In one of his early poems, O'Neill adumbrates his vision, as he compares his soul to a submarine and his aspirations to torpedo directed towards "the grimy galleons of commerce" (Brustein 1964, 328).

 
 
 

American Literature Journal, Illusion Versus Reality, Eugene O'Neill, Democratic Idealism, Commercial Values, Glorious Illusions, Psychological Tension, Caribbean Island, Electra Complex, Ancient Greek Myth, Poetical Interpretation, Mutual Deception.