IUP Publications Online
Home About IUP Magazines Journals Books Archives
     
A Guided Tour | Recommend | Links | Subscriber Services | Feedback | Subscribe Online
 
The IUP Journal of American Literature
A Comparative Study of the Protagonists in William Shakespeare's King Lear and Arthur Miller's All My Sons
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

This paper presents a comparative study of the protagonists in William Shakespeare's King Lear and Arthur Miller'sAll My Sons. In these plays, the problem concerns the conflicting self-image and the notion of self-identity of the parent, leading to a parent-child conflict. Like Lear inKing Lear, Joe Keller in All My Sons is a doting and loving father. While Joe Keller's self-contradictory image, that of a loving father and of a corrupt businessman, proves to be his undoing, Lear's possessiveness and demanding nature, in spite of his love for his daughters, bring about his downfall. The paper takes a close look at the flawed thinking of these two individuals and presents it as the root cause of their tragic failure.

 
 
 

World literature and its numerous interpretations have proved the point that diverse human emotions find reflection in literature, as literature is the mirror not only of society but also of human feelings and aspirations. And the study of comparative literature helps in giving us a better picture of ourselves in relation to those who lived in another time and at another place.

In the plays, All My Sons and King Lear, the problem is of the conflicting self-image and the notion of self-identity. In both these plays, the relationship between the parent and child is threatened due to the tug-of-war between them. The parent is either too dominating or too possessive, and the child, on the other hand, tries to challenge the image of the parent. This `war' between the parent and the child is not spontaneous. As Koch (1967, 103) rightly remarks, "War is not a spontaneous phenomenon; it is only the intensification of forces already at work during the interludes of peace like humidity gathering before a storm."

Joe Keller in All My Sons is a man of self-contradictory imagesone of a loving father and caring husband, and the other of a shrewd and corrupt businessman. As a father and husband, he is concerned with the wellbeing of his family; but as a businessman, he adopts unfair means to earn moneyhe supplies defective cylinder heads to the American Air Force, as a result of which twenty-one pilots lose their lives. The struggle between these two conflicting images is the crux of Joe's personality.

 
 
 

American Literature Journal, William Shakespeares King Lear, American Air Force, Goddam Business, Criminal Negligence, Business Ethics, Government Contract, American Business, Moral Considerations, Ethical Principles, Heartbreaking Denunciation.