In Asia, the US put forward a bilateral approach by the establishment of
bilateral military alliance with various individual Asian countries such as Japan, South
Korea, Philippines, etc. In contrast, the US put into practice a multilateral approach
in Western Europe within the framework of the Marshall Plan and forced the
Western European countries to work together as a group in order to receive the
Marshall Plan assistance although the initial objective of the Plan was not to support
the European integration.
The People's Republic of China was forced to carry out a so-called `lean to
one side' foreign policy and became the member of the Socialist Camp led by the
Soviet Union because of the Korean War started in 1950. The Socialist Camp and
the Warsaw Pact Organization could be regarded as a multilateral arrangement
among the Socialist countries during the 1950s and 1960s. It was also because of the
bad experience with the Socialist Camp, the multilateral approach was regarded by
the Chinese as a kind of hegemonic system. China finally broke with the Soviet
Union, dropped out of the Socialist Camp and put in practice the so-called independent and
self-determinate foreign policy. Not only the US but also the Soviet Union was
defined as the hegemony in a very negative term. From the late 1950s to 1980s, China
kept its position of unilateralism and bilateralism in the foreign relations, and
strongly supported the non-alignment
movement.
Multilateralism was not very popular in China
before the 1990s. It was put on the Chinese foreign policy agenda just several years before.
Before the 1990s, what the Chinese concentrated on was multipolarity instead of multilateralism.
In both theoretic and pragmatic terms, multipolarity was a kind of balance
of power that was favored by many Chinese. During
the late 1990s, Chinese scholars started to challenge the concept of multipolarity and advocated pluralism as
the replacement and argued that the tendency in the post-cold war era was
non-polarity instead of multipolarity. In July 2001, the first academic
conference was held in Beijing to discuss multilateralism and multilateral diplomacy and
eight conference papers were published by World Economics and
Politics, a very influential journal on international studies in China in October
2001. It was the first time for the Chinese scholars to look at multilateralism from
both the theoretical and policy perspective. But the Chinese understanding
of multilateralism at that time was still very much the same as balance of powers and
multipolarity. Some of them argued that multilateral diplomacy was
the most important approach to the multipolar
world. |