Everything
in this world has an ex-piry date: Aspirin of Bayer, VS Naipaul
of literature, Ramanna of BARC, Dilip Kumar of Bollywood,
even Lata Mangeshkar of the music world, but not the "reservations"
of India. The recent announcement of Ministry of HRD proposing
to create reservations for Other Backward Classes (OBCs) to
the extent of 27% over and above the existing 22.5% for Schedule
Castes and Schedule Tribes (SCSTs), in central educational
institutions including the Indian Institutes of Technology
(IITs), Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs), Central Universities,
etc., and the consequent reactions of the society would corroborate
the statement. It is averred that the present proposal is
an outcome of the 93rd Constitutional Amendment
Act, which enables the state to offer special provisions for
the advancement of backward classes in "educational institutions
including private educational institutions, whether aided
or unaided by the State, other than minority educational institutions".
But the 93rd Constitutional Amendment Act has only
an enabling clause to offer such reservations; it is not mandatory.
The impact of the proposal could be gauged from the fact that
every year nearly four lakh students appear for entrance test
to secure admission in the 4,500 odd seats on offer in the
seven IITs, which would now stand reduced by a whopping 1200
seats under the "merit" category.
It
is further feared that the government may extend "quotas"
to private educational institutes, foreign universities operating
from India and even private businesses for employment. This
has obviously raked up a fresh debate nationwide. Reacting
to the proposals, Mr. Ratan Tata, Chairman of Tata Sons, as
quoted in The Hindu, said: "Though I do not want
to comment on it, it (reservation) is bad In some way it will
tend to divide the country into different groups". That
aside, the current move, unlike that of yesteryear's propositions,
merits critical examination from the perspective of the ongoing
"globalization" process, is an altogether different
ball game of economic pursuits that the country is engaged
in. |