Home About IUP Magazines Journals Books Amicus Archives
     
A Guided Tour | Recommend | Links | Subscriber Services | Feedback | Subscribe Online
 
The Analyst Magazine:
The Real `Catcher in the Rye: Is it a Mere Conjecture?
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 
 
 

I set off to write here about a subject which unceasingly attracts both raw fervor and scholarly undertakings: Its about Holden Caulfield, the super cool American disaffected youth, who has come to exemplify the almost Hamlet-like revulsion for the "rank and base things" of the world; Only, unlike the prince of Denmark, Caulfield was all of 16 years, flunking his way out of yet another elite prep school, all the while articulating a profound distaste for all things phony. He also differed from Hamlet in another crucial aspect: his manner of articulation: breezy, impudent and endearing; none of the exalted but pedantic bemoans of Hamlet.

My enterprise here is not to heap another richly deserved eulogy on the catcher in the rye, not even to once again commend its brilliant and famously reclusive writer JD Salinger. I want to put forth here a conjecture which struck my fancy; I want to promulgate the idea of Thomas Dequincy, that infamous and luminous writer of "confessions of the English opium eater" as one who embodies the traits that Holden Caulfield is loved and revered for.

Like Caulfield, Dequincy was both derelict and disillusioned. He too played the truant from his own academic pursuits, to the point of seceding from both family and school. Like Caulfield, Dequincy displays an unfailing reverence for the classics, and an inveterate reader.

 
 
 

elite prep, school, profound, distaste, phony,Hamlet, crucial, aspect, manner, articulation, breezy, impudent, endearing; exalted , pedantic,bemoans ,Hamlet.