When the Beatles visited
the US for the first time,
the crowd was going berserk to catch a glimpse of the
group that was more popular than Jesus (sic). The Beatles looked around
and breathed "So this is America. They all seem mad."
When an average Indian thinks about the USto a large number
of our countrymen, the US is synonymous with the developed
countries of the worldhe thinks of them as `Inscrutable Americans.' There is
a marked dichotomy in our perception. On one hand, the mind
conjures up images of a wonderfully developed country and
confident people. On the other hand, we can only think of them as an
excessively permissive society, lacking moral values and social moorings. We
self-righteously dismiss them in the same words of the Beatle
assessment. Statistics back up our belief. There were 40,867 clinically active
psychiatrists in the US in 2000, according to the AMA data. At the
other extreme are we Indians, where the total number of trained
psychiatrists in India is less than 1000. And, if we recall the laws of
supply and demand, we condescendingly conclude that more Americans
(and other white races) need psychiatric help than we do in India. We
congratulate ourselves on the family and social support system that
helps in the holistic development of the child and makes balanced
adults, high on emotional and spirituality quotient.
People with advanced mental illnesses of course go to mental
asylums, and therapeutic centers (In India, in most cases, we simply
put them in jail for want of better options). But why does an
average westerner with no discernible mental illness go to a psychiatrist or
a counselor? According to James H Scully, MD and Joshua E Wilk,
"On an average a psychiatrist sees 41 patients in a week" (data for
2002).
People seek professional help for maladjustments, stress,
emotional upheavals, anxiety, guilt, low self worth and lack of confidence. In
an interview with Britain's Radio Times
Magazine, the former Beatle, Paul McCartney, said he had sought
solace in writing music, but had been helped by professional
psychiatric counseling. "It is not a bad idea
to have someone to talk to. Its normally over family
matters." McCartney said. |