A student once defined the Masters of Business Administration
degree to me as `common sense, with a dash of pseudoscience.'
Whether he was correct or not is a matter of opinion, but
an area where criticism does strike home relates to the
way culture is presented to aspiring managers. It is presented
as far more concrete, explanatory and threatening than is
usually the case. Culture, after all, is highly visible
in many of its aspects, which readily leads to `attribution
bias'to attributing to it behavior that probably has
quite different causes.
The mindset that thinks in terms of cultural explanation
is very common, even among academics. Some experts of multi-country
studies are actually asked why they have not cited culture
as an explanation of the differences reported in the course
of their research, even when they have discovered that differences
are greater from person to person than when people are grouped
by nationality. Furthermore, cultural exceptionalism springs
readily to the minds of many in politics, who make claims
for the antiquity and significance of a culture that they
wish to see protected. Since sets of behavior that can be
labeled cultural are so numerous and their characteristics
apparently so obvious, it is easy to label any given set
as distinct and claim a privileged status for it.
|