June'20
Entrepreneurship Education Ecosystem in India: Current Practice and Proposed Framework
Sana Shawl
Research Scholar, Department of Management Studies, University of Kashmir, Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir,
India. E-mail: sanashawll@gmail.com
The purpose of this study is to evaluate the cognitive development and expertise of entrepreneurs and the impact thereof on the success of entrepreneurship. The existing theory on success factors for entrepreneurs is lacking in relation to the cognitive development and expertise of entrepreneurs. A qualitative research in the form of semi-structured interviews with experienced entrepreneurs was conducted. Data analysis and interpretation were undertaken using thematic analysis. The findings revealed that experienced entrepreneurs are characterized by enhanced quality of thinking and depth of processing information. This gives them the capability to schematically map interconnections by identifying problems and designing solutions for complex opportunities. In addition, it appears that experience is compulsory for novices to develop into experts. Consequently, a prolonged duration of exposure is required for novices to develop expertise. An evaluation of faster and effective methods of transferring entrepreneurship experience is necessary to expedite expertise.
Introduction
The belief that entrepreneurs are born and cannot be made does not hold good anymore.
Although many would argue that an entrepreneurial spirit is inborn and entrepreneurship
cannot be taught as a subject to inculcate entrepreneurial skills among individuals,
entrepreneurship education has achieved a global status for itself, offered in both developed and developing countries. According to "Special Report: A Global Perspective on
Entrepreneurship Education and Training", GEM, 2008, entrepreneurship education is broadly defined as, "The building of knowledge and skills for the purpose of entrepreneurship,
generally as part of recognized education programs at primary, secondary or tertiary-level
educational institutions."
Entrepreneurial skills include 'soft' skills, such as persistence, networking, problemsolving,
teamwork, communication, leadership, decision making, self-confidence on the one
hand and 'enabling' skills on the other hand, such as basic business knowledge, business
planning, financial literacy, technical and managerial skills. An effective entrepreneurship
education policy is a prerequisite for any economy aiming to develop the entrepreneurial
skills among its people, the broader objective of which is not only to increase the number
of individuals starting their own ventures, but also to develop an entrepreneurial culture
which in turn can help fulfill the socioeconomic objectives of a nation.
Entrepreneurship as a key driver of economic growth and a backbone of economic
development has largely inspired the development of entrepreneurship as a field of study in
business courses across the globe (Arthur et al., 2012). Entrepreneurship education has a
multiplier effect demonstrated as shown in Figure 1.
Literature Review
Researchers argue that entrepreneurship development is the central focus of many
governments across the world (Hannon, 2006; and Minniti and Levesque, 2008). It has also
been argued that policy-makers recognize the importance of entrepreneurship education and
training as "an effective mechanism for fostering the entrepreneurial activities" (Martinez
et al., 2010). This conducive policy environment has contributed to a number of programs being offered in entrepreneurship in various forms globally (Atherton, 2004; Fayolle, 2004;
Hytti and O'Gorman, 2004; and Klapper, 2004). Casson (2000) argues that every individual
within the contemporary economy can be an entrepreneur and some other researchers claim
that entrepreneurship education and training should be imparted to each and every individual
(Gibb, 2002). It has, however, proven to be very difficult for nations to validate the
contribution of entrepreneurship education to the economy.
Matlay (2008) made an attempt to investigate the effect of entrepreneurship education on
entrepreneurial outcomes. He took a cohort of 64 graduate entrepreneurs from 8 higher
education institutes in the UK who had undertaken entrepreneurship education courses. The
researcher conducted semi-structured interviews from year 1997 to 2006 to assess the
progression of these students from their graduation to entrepreneurial journey. The results
suggest that there is a mismatch between needs for entrepreneurship education and actual
learning outcomes with regard to entrepreneurial skills, knowledge and attitudes. However,
it has been observed that these graduate entrepreneurs are usually satisfied with the result of
entrepreneurship education.
Researchers have differentiated entrepreneurship education from general education
arguing that entrepreneurship education focuses on developing entrepreneurial skills and
fostering entrepreneurship (Verheul et al., 2001). Robinson and Sexton (2002) studied the
impact of education on individuals taking up entrepreneurial activities. It has been found that
general education exerts a strong impact on entrepreneurship leading to success. Dickson
et al. (2008) investigated the relationship between general education, specific types of
entrepreneurship education and entrepreneurial activities. It is found that there exists a strong
relationship between general education and several entrepreneurial success measures. The
results are, however, ambiguous with regard to the link between general education and the
choice to become an entrepreneur. The results having a linkage between specific
entrepreneurship education programs and entrepreneurship, although less clear, suggest a
positive relationship between such education and choice to become an entrepreneur and
subsequently entrepreneurial success. Experience has a similar relationship although not as
strong. However, the relationship between entrepreneurship education and economic
performance is not really clear. Instead, attainment of higher education in a general form has
been found to be more common among entrepreneurs than education specifically targeted
towards entrepreneurship (Bennett and Dann, 2000). Many studies reveal that entrepreneurs
of developed countries show higher success rates only when they have attained higher levels
of education (Lee, 1997; Foley and Griffith, 1998; Van der Sluis et al., 2003; and Leffler and
Svedberg, 2005) and such effect is more pronounced when higher education is coupled with
experience (Scott et al., 1998). Further, a relationship has been found between higher
education levels and start-up activities among the countries that generally contribute to the
Global Entrepreneurship Monitor (GEM) study (Minniti et al., 2006). It has also been
observed that the entrepreneurs who have attained general higher education levels gain better
access to capital which in turn contributes to their performance (Parker and van Praag, 2006).
In such cases, general higher education and not the entrepreneurship education contributes
to the success and performance of businesses.
Another group of researchers have found that entrepreneurial tendencies and behavior are
strongly affected by entrepreneurship education (Sexton and Bowman, 1983; Kolvereid and
Moen, 1997; and Henderson and Robertson, 1999). Further, studies have found links existing
between entrepreneurship, education and personality characteristics (Luthje and Franke, 2002)
while some others revealed a link to personal cognitive infrastructure (Krueger, 2000; and
Mitchell et al., 2002). Entrepreneurial cognition tends to be strengthened by factors other than
education such as cultural and social values (Mitchell et al., 2002). Karanja et al. (2016) state
that the entrepreneurial curriculum significantly contributes in influencing an entrepreneurial
mindset among the students subjected to entrepreneurship education.
Research Gap and Problem Statement
Though researchers agree that entrepreneurship education is being imparted to inculcate
entrepreneurial skill among individuals but the impact of such educational initiatives is
highly debatable. This review brings the fact to us that much literature is focused on western
countries and very few studies have been conducted on entrepreneurship education in the
Indian context. Thus, there is a need for studying the overall entrepreneurship education
ecosystem in India in a holistic manner. Moreover, as the review suggests that many
researchers argue that higher education leads to better entrepreneurial outcome than specific
entrepreneurship education, specific entrepreneurship education is nowadays being imparted
at higher education level which needs to be examined in this background. This paper,
therefore, addresses these needs and makes an attempt to study entrepreneurship education
ecosystem across all levels in the country. In addition to this, the paper studies the challenges
faced by entrepreneurship education in India and suggests a working framework for improving
entrepreneurship education ecosystem in the country leading to a better entrepreneurial
ecosystem, ultimately translating into sustainable economic development which is considered
to be an important policy objective of the nation.
Objective
The present study aims to achieve the following objectives:
Entrepreneurship Education Ecosystem in India
Ignoring such controversies on whether entrepreneurship education leads to entrepreneurial
activities in an economy or not, many top business schools offer entrepreneurship education
to the students of management in order to teach them entrepreneurial skills, thereby making
an effort to build an entrepreneurial culture in a nation. Developing entrepreneurship as a field
of study has been primarily driven by the recognition of entrepreneurship as an important tool
for generating economic growth.
Entrepreneurship has been strongly encouraged in Indian economy after the move of
liberalization in the 1990s by reducing the entry barriers for start-ups, reducing capital
constraints for them and establishing institutions for the development of entrepreneurial talent.
The transition of economy from being agrarian into one that has remarkable contribution from
other sectors has highlighted the crucial role of education to develop entrepreneurial
competencies among individuals thereby enabling entrepreneurial activities in these emerging
sectors. Among other factors necessary for entrepreneurship development, an effective
entrepreneurship education ecosystem has become the focus of many developing economies. It
is important to realize the significance of entrepreneurship education for the economic
upliftment of an emerging economy such as India (Todd and Javalgi, 2007). Entrepreneurship
education and training is imparted across various levels in India in order to foster
entrepreneurship with the ultimate objective of achieving balanced socioeconomic development.
Role of Government in Developing Entrepreneurial Skill at the School Level
The Government of India plays an important role in inculcating entrepreneurial skill among
individuals right from the school level with the ultimate objective of building an effective
start-up ecosystem in the country. It has setup the Atal Innovation Mission (AIM) at NITI
Aayog. With the mission of transforming India into an innovative country, AIM established
a network of Atal Tinkering Laboratories (ATL) in the schools. ATL is a workspace where
entrepreneurial and innovation skills are inculcated among the school students by
encouraging 'Do It Yourself' type of projects aiming to foster curiosity, creativity and
imagination in young minds. ATLs are established in schools (Grade VI-XII) managed by
government, local body or private trusts/society. AIM has selected 2,441 schools across India
to establish ATLs and these innovation workspaces equipped with state-of-the-art
technologies have exposed the students to technology platforms where students have already
started designing prototype solutions and creative projects such as better irrigation
management, waste management and sensor-based solutions in such labs. As per the GEM
report (2016), India ranks at 10th place in school-level entrepreneurship education among the
65 nations that contribute to GEM study. Government initiatives like Atal Tinkering Labs can
go a long way in helping young individuals realize their entrepreneurial tendencies and
developing a strong entrepreneurial culture.
Role of Higher Education Institutions in Entrepreneurship Education
Entrepreneurship education has proven to be effective globally at the higher education level,
where students pursue short-term as well as long-term courses in entrepreneurship and participate in entrepreneurship focused projects and activities. According to Entrepreneurship
Policy Framework suggested by UNCTAD, it is important to expose students to entrepreneurship education before they choose their specialization in the university.
The higher education system in India exhibits an increasing trend to develop
entrepreneurial capabilities among students by offering entrepreneurship as a core subject in
business education. Full-time entrepreneurship courses are being offered by many institutes
like IIMs, IISc Bangalore, XLRI, NMIMS, ISB Hyderabad and other institutes of good repute.
Initiatives are being taken by universities to help the students gain the necessary skill and
confidence to translate their business ideas into a real business opportunity. Incubation
centers are also growing in number in Indian universities and autonomous organizations
which not only help the budding start-ups with the basic business skills but offer a complete
hand-holding by providing services like co-working space, access to markets and finance,
networking opportunities and help with regulatory compliance.
The entrepreneurship education ecosystem in India has effectively promoted the concept
of Faculty-Student Collaboration which brings together faculty members and students to work
on their own business ideas. IITs lead this collaborative trend across India including Mumbai,
Delhi, Chennai, Kharagpur and Hyderabad. IIT Madras Incubation Cell (IITMIC) recognized
as Technology Business Incubator by National Science and Technology Entrepreneurship
Development Board (NSTEDB), has incubated 91 companies founded by collaboration
between students and the faculty. Even in the technology startups incubated in IITMIC, the
faculty members are seen as founders or minority shareholders. At Society for Innovation and
Entrepreneurship (SINE), IIT Bombay, more than 40% of the business projects are joint
ventures between faculty and students. IIT Hyderabad has also incubated successful startups
based on faculty-student collaboration.
Recognizing the role of networking and knowledge partnership in entrepreneurship
development, N S Raghavan Center for Entrepreneurial Learning of IIM Bangalore (NSRCELIIMB)
has conducted international collaboration projects. The Global Entrepreneurship
Monitor (GEM) Project with the London Business School, Kaufmann Foundation, and Babson
College has been a major one. Likewise, IIM Calcutta's entrepreneurship cell is globally
known for holding the biggest business plan contest in Asia, i2I-ideas to implementation
in collaboration with Yale University's Yale Entrepreneurial Society (YES).
The well reputed institutes play a significant role in creating a vibrant startup ecosystem
in India by promoting innovative entrepreneurial activities in their incubation facilities. At
NSRCEL-IIMB, the eligibility for aspiring entrepreneurs to be a part of incubation center is
to fulfill the "3 I" criteria of being innovative, impact making and implementable. The
Innovation Center at International Institute of Information Technology, Bangalore offers short
and medium term programs like Cube, Axle and Nova to provide end-to-end incubation
services to the potential ventures. IIIT-B Innovation Center, an open incubator selects startups
on the basis of three criteria; Novel (originality in the business idea), Non-Trivial (ability
to create entry barrier for the competitor) and Useful (ability to turn an idea into a commercial
offering within 18-24 months). The Entrepreneurship Development Cell, IIT Delhi strives hard to develop a sustainable entrepreneurship ecosystem in the country by creating a wide range
of entrepreneurial resources with easy access to aspiring entrepreneurs, through fun filled yet
highly educating sessions like Startup Showcases, Business Plan Competitions, eTalks and so on.
Role of Entrepreneurship Development Institutes in Entrepreneurship
Education
Government of India has established entrepreneurship development institutes in different
states of the country with the aim of developing entrepreneurial talent and enabling effective
entrepreneurship. The notable ones like National Institute of Entrepreneur and Small Business
Development (NIESBUD), Entrepreneurial Development Institute of India (EDII), Indian
Institute of Entrepreneurship (IIE) conduct Entrepreneurship Development Programs (EDPs)
through a team of trainers who provide training to potential entrepreneurs to help them
establish their own ventures by imparting necessary knowledge and skill about the important
aspects of business. The entrepreneurial skills are imparted to trainees through experientiallearning
by simulation method, structured discussions, motivation sessions and business plan
trainings. In order to cater to the specific needs of aspiring entrepreneurs across different
sectors, sector-specific trainings are conducted by the entrepreneurship development institutes
in collaboration with industry.
Challenges to Effective Entrepreneurship Education in India
Although India has exerted tremendous effort in developing entrepreneurship through
educational initiatives across various levels, there are several challenges to building an
effective entrepreneurship education ecosystem. Entrepreneurship as an academic subject is
yet to achieve the status of a preferred course among business students of the country. Shankar
(2012) argues that this is the reason strong enough for many educational institutions to offer
entrepreneurship only as a co-curricular or extra-curricular program. He identifies six primary
obstacles to teaching entrepreneurship in India:
It has been observed that in India entrepreneurship education is promoted more at the
higher education level than at the school level which acts as a barrier to developing an
entrepreneurial mindset among individuals from an early stage. The educational institutes that
offer business education with a special focus on student entrepreneurship have not developed
a satisfactory entrepreneurial curriculum for inculcating entrepreneurial skill as well as spirit
among students (Dutta, 2012; and Mutsuddi, 2012). Moreover, it has been observed that there is a lack of entrepreneurship education and training for non-business students at higher
education level as an entrepreneurship course is still mostly offered in business and economics studies, and to a small extent to engineering students.
While the economic development of a country largely depends on rural development, the
environment faced by rural entrepreneurs in India is not conducive to entrepreneurship
development. The reasons may be lack of awareness of the entrepreneurial opportunities and
low level of entrepreneurial skill among the rural populace (Saxena, 2012).
In this existing scenario, the challenge is to expand the scope and focus of
entrepreneurship education in India and adopt a robust and innovative approach in
redesigning the education system for better entrepreneurial outcome.
Proposed Framework for Effective Entrepreneurship Education
Ecosystem
The different stakeholders in India have come forward to nurture the entrepreneurial mindset
of youth but there is a tremendous scope of improvement as well as a need for building a more
conducive educational ecosystem. In this context, the author suggests a framework to enable
an effective entrepreneurship education ecosystem in the country.
In developing economies like India, after attaining primary level education the enrolment
rates may come down which emphasizes the priority of considering entrepreneurship from an
early stage. Thus, much focus should be on developing entrepreneurial awareness and
behavior at primary level through innovative approaches. Lessons should be learnt from
educational initiatives taken globally. In collaboration with the Kauffman Foundation,
Disney's Hot Shot Business online game has achieved remarkable success in teaching children
aged 9-14 years about the exciting field of entrepreneurship, reaching more than 20 million
young people annually.
Maria et al. (2017) argues that entrepreneurial skill can be inculcated among individuals
at the elementary school level. The Mexican sub-program "My First Company: Entrepreneurship
by Playing" was the Educational Experience (EE) which showed the importance of subjecting
an individual to entrepreneurship at an early stage. The researcher argues that educational
experience can go a long way in improving the socioeconomic situation of individuals and
enhancing the entrepreneurial tendencies specifically so in developing countries.
Outside of the formal education system, informal training programs should be targeted at
rural and underserved groups to promote entrepreneurial spirit and inculcate entrepreneurial
skill across communities. As per UNCTAD Entrepreneurship Policy Framework, extracurricular
activities for students like visits to businesses should be undertaken as such
practices have yielded beneficial results in some countries.
At university level, more efforts should be made in establishing and developing
incubation centers where worthy business ideas should be incubated. Universities should
develop their own network of mentors available to provide expert guidance to start-ups.
Entrepreneurship education should not be limited to business students but efforts should be made by universities to promote such education across disciplines by offering entrepreneurship
as a core subject. Onuma (2016) states that entrepreneurship education is imperative across
all disciplines. Moreover, effective entrepreneurship curriculum should be developed which
not only focuses on teaching basic entrepreneurial skills but also encourage experiential
learning techniques and customized sector-oriented training programs. Karanja et al. (2016)
suggested that entrepreneurship curriculum should focus on case studies, enable partnering
with businessmen, and accessing role models to acquaint students with technological and
other important aspects related to business.
Online and part-time training courses should be conducted to target those aspiring
entrepreneurs who may find it difficult to undertake a regular course. Trainees' peer network
should be developed to bring together committed entrepreneurs under one platform which
may further enable effective entrepreneurship through networking effects. Awareness should
be created about the online learning resources available to aspiring entrepreneurs free of cost.
Private enterprises should collaborate with entrepreneurship development centers and
institutes involved in entrepreneurship education and training. Such collaboration with
private enterprises can guide the potential start-ups in launching their own business
enterprises and solve real business problems. Government should encourage such collaboration
by means of incentives. Furthermore, government should invest in training the teachers and
trainers imparting entrepreneurship education, necessary for meaningful and result-oriented
entrepreneurship education.
Conclusion
India is becoming a breeding ground for startups due to the economic benefits attached to
the entrepreneurial activities of such startups. In order to expand the entrepreneurial activity,
entrepreneurship education is being offered across various levels in the country. Research
provides conflicting evidence on whether such educational interventions actually promote
entrepreneurial outcome as it has been difficult to substantiate the contribution of
entrepreneurship education to the economy. Ignoring such controversies, the education
ecosystem in India has witnessed an increasing number of entrepreneurship education and
training programs. The result-oriented and innovative approaches have been adopted by
government and educational institutions in imparting entrepreneurship education. However,
entrepreneurship is yet to enjoy the status of a preferred course among students and potential
entrepreneurs, calling for an urgent need to improve the relevance of the existing educational
programs. This paper proposes a working framework, subject to further research for
redesigning the entrepreneurship education ecosystem in the country in order to achieve
better entrepreneurial outcome, thereby leading to sustainable economic development.
Limitations and Scope for Future Research: Since the paper is conceptual in nature, the
limitation in the same is that the researcher has not conducted any empirical analysis. It
provides a holistic view about the present entrepreneurship education ecosystem in the
country and thus offers an opportunity to researchers in this area to empirically evaluate the
effectiveness of the entrepreneurship education initiatives undertaken across different levels that is the training and skill development programs being offered to potential entrepreneurs
at primary, secondary and tertiary level in future course of time.