Nov'21

The IUP Journal of Bank Management

Focus

One of the most perplexing issues confronted by bank managers is demystifying the effect of capital structure on bank profitability. Bank capital has an all-important role as it acts as a self-insurance against bank runs and helps manage the risks more prudently. Since the bank shareholders have more skin in the game as the capital increases, the managers will act more carefully without causing losses. Given this rationale, enough capital is critical for faster banking development.

Adequate bank capital is crucial because of the following reasons. First, undercapitalized banks cannot provide ample credit to borrowers. Second, undercapitalized banks may evergreen their loans to zombie businesses, thus undermining the banking activities. Third, an undercapitalized banking system is vulnerable to crisis-contagion. How do banks look at their capital structure? Drawing inferences from the classical theory of corporate finance-the Modigliani-Miller (MM) theorem-banks tend to violate the MM assumptions under a specific set of circumstances, for they "will be indifferent between equity and debt finance". Given an opportunity to choose, the banks typically go with debt capital, thus minimizing their reliance on equity capital.

Why do banks prefer debt to equity? Because they perceive equity as expensive compared to debt as a means of capital. Higher capital requirements in terms of higher levels of equity raise banks' private costs. However, they increase the ability of the banks to face difficult times by not chucking the risks on to the clientele. As capital is an important source of funds for the banks to acquire assets, the capital structure assumes greater significance. Much research is available on the effects of capital structure on bank performance, yet the ever-changing landscape requires a critical analysis of the bank capital structure to elicit better insights.

The first paper , "The Impact of Capital Structure on the Profitability of Nepalese Commercial Banks", presents an interesting analysis of the capital structure of Nepalese commercial banks and its effect on bank profitability. The authors, Radhe Shyam Pradhan and Krishna Maya Kafle, study the capital structure of 28 commercial banks in the land-locked country of Nepal for the period 2010-11 to 2018-19. The study examines five hypotheses:

(i) Does capital adequacy have a positive relationship with bank profitability? (ii) Does the debt level of the banks positively impact profitability? (iii) Is there a negative relationship between debt-equity ratio and bank profitability? (iv) Does bank size negatively impact bank profitability? and (v) Does the short-term debt to total assets ratio impact bank profitability positively? Their findings reveal that the debt-assets ratio, debt-equity ratio, and short-term debt to assets ratio have a negative association with return on assets. Similarly, capital adequacy ratio, debt-equity ratio, and short-term debt to assets ratio show a negative association with return on equity. However, the total debt-assets ratio and bank size show a positive association with net interest margin and return on equity. Further, the authors observe that bank size is the most influencing factor in explaining the changes in bank profitability.

In the second paper, "Issues in Group Lending as a Source of Microfinance: A Literature Review", the authors, Nishi Malhotra and Pankaj Baag, explore the challenges faced by Joint Liability Groups (JLGs) while providing credit to the unbanked and the underbanked. Applying the agency theory and social contracting concepts, the review observes that most underbanked and unbanked persons suffer from a lack of collateral and creditworthiness. Accordingly, the lenders face the problems of moral hazard and adverse selection. In overcoming such challenges, the JLGs are found to use peer monitoring methods and rely on social capital to finance the economically poor. The study observes that the group's success is determined by financial literacy and social intermediation. Peer monitoring and enforcement are found to help improve loan repayments and the financial sustainability of JLGs. The authors note that building credit agreements and proper social contracts with micro-borrowers will enhance the efficacy of financial intermediation through JLGs. The last paper, "Payments Banks in India: An Analysis of Their Business Performance", presents an interesting assessment of the role played by the payments banks in India in providing low-value payment services and accepting small deposits with the use of sophisticated financial technologies in aiding financial inclusion. The author, V S Kaveri, observes that payments banks will experience a breakthrough in their size and composition of business in the immediate future as digital banking gains prominence. Further, the author emphasizes that promoting customer education in digital banking, particularly in rural areas, will hugely benefit these payments banks in meeting their expectations in terms of reach and business viability.

- Vighneswara Swamy
Consulting Editor

Article   Price (₹)
The Impact of Capital Structure on the Profitability of Nepalese Commercial Banks
100
Issues in Group Lending as a Source of Microfinance: A Literature Review
100
Payments Banks in India: An Analysis of Their Business Performance
100
Contents : (Nov' 21)

The Impact of Capital Structure on the Profitability of Nepalese Commercial Banks
Radhe Shyam Pradhan and Krishna Maya Kafle

This study examines the impact of capital structure on the profitability of Nepalese commercial banks. Return on assets, return on equity and net interest margin are selected as the dependent variables. The selected independent variables are capital adequacy ratio, bank size, total debt to total assets ratio, total debt to total equity ratio and short- term debt to total assets ratio. The study is based on the secondary data of 28 commercial banks with 224 observations for the period 2011-12 to 2018-19. The data is collected from the Banking and Financial Statistics published by Nepal Rastra Bank and annual reports of the selected commercial banks. The regression models are estimated to test the impact of capital structure on the profitability of Nepalese commercial banks. The study showed that short-term debt to total assets ratio has a negative impact on return on equity, return on assets and net interest margin. It indicates that increase in short- term debt to total assets ratio leads to a decrease in return on equity, return on assets and net interest margin. Similarly, total debt to total assets ratio has a negative impact on return on assets. It indicates that increase in total debt to total assets ratio leads to a decrease in return on assets. Likewise, total debt to total equity ratio has a negative impact on return on equity, return on assets and net interest margin. It means that increase in total debt to total equity ratio leads to a decrease in return on equity, return on assets and net interest margin. Further, there is a negative impact of capital adequacy ratio on return on equity. This means that increase in capital adequacy ratio leads to decrease in return on equity. However, bank size has a positive impact on return on equity, return on assets and net interest margin. It indicates that the larger the bank size, the higher would be the return on equity, return on assets and net interest margin.


© 2021 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : Rs.100

Issues in Group Lending as a Source of Microfinance: A Literature Review
Nishi Malhotra and Pankaj Baag

Using agency theory as theoretical lens, this paper examines the obstacles that Joint Liability Groups (JLGs) face in providing credit to the unbanked and the underbanked. A thorough literature study was used to analyze the data. Most underbanked and unbanked persons lack collateral, and lenders know nothing about their creditworthiness. Thus, moral hazard and adverse selection are concerns. Large banks are not willing to provide access to finance to micro borrowers. JLGs use peer monitoring and social capital to help the poor and unbanked have access to financial services. In addition, the study demonstrates the importance of risk and social homogeneity in JLG's success monitoring. As a result of the absence of regulation, JLGs are unable to preserve financial records or have regular meetings. The group's success is determined by financial literacy and social intermediation. This study is the first to examine SBLP (Self-Help Group- Bank Linkage Program) via the lens of agency theory and social contracting, and will be of interest to academics and bankers. It found that peer monitoring and enforcement can help increase loan repayments and financial sustainability for JLGs. This study will also help build collective credit agreements and social contracts for micro borrowers through JLGs.


© 2021 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : Rs.100

Payments Banks in India: An Analysis of Their Business Performance
V S Kaveri

In the context of promotion of financial inclusion in India, Payments Banks (PBs) have a key role to play as they accept small deposits from the poor and offer them low value remittance services. The unique feature of PBs is the size of remittances performed through technology platform being too large and value of each transaction being too small. Consequently, risk in remittance services is high and increasing. Therefore, Reserve Bank of India (RBI) imposed regulatory compliance norms on the part of PBs, which include minimum capital, Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR), deployment of deposits in government securities, Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR) and best management practices. These are expected to ensure the financial soundness of PBs, strengthen safety in remittance services and protect the interests of small customers at large. Though the number of PBs is just six at present, considering the emerging business potential, a few more PBs are expected to come up. But from the study of financial analysis of PBs, it is observed that they face numerous issues which need to be addressed. Towards this end, the paper offers suggestions, besides discussing the origin, regulatory aspects, activity profile and performance review of PBs.


© 2021 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : Rs.100