December '2020

The IUP Journal of Financial Risk Management

Focus

For asset management, its valuation and pricing, rating migration matrices are irreplaceable-a service typically provided by rating agencies but subject to criticism for not being on time and for their inaccuracies. The second paper, "Decomposing Rating Migration Matrices from Market Prices: Sources of Nonlinearity and Resolve", by Brian Barnard, decomposes rating migration matrices from market prices. The study outlines sources of nonlinearity and complexity of the optimization problem. Rating category migration of values and spacing is captured in the study. Overall, revisiting and re-examining the way the optimization algorithm searches optimal solutions based on the initial solution provided, can further improve decomposition results.

The third paper, "Rainfall Forecasting Announcement and Commodity Spot Price Fluctuation: Evidence from Six Selected Food Commodities with Reference to Indian Commodity Market", by Mohd Merajuddin Inamdar, Susanta Datta and Vinayak Karande, uses daily spot price data from January 2, 2017 to December 13, 2017, and uses two rainfall forecasting announcement dates, April 18, 2017 and June 6, 2017, by the Indian Meteorological Department, Government of India. The effect of rainfall prediction announcement on six different commodity spot price fluctuations is examined in this paper. Rainfall forecasting is a very intermittent phenomenon, and there is no clear evidence of market volatility in product spot markets. They are in line with the reality that agricultural commodity pricing is affected by seasonality, which can last for a limited period of time. Weather information can be made more easily available to merchants and farmers using information technologies and connectivity so that markets match fair prices. Weather derivatives should be seen by the market regulator as a way to hedge potential agro-commodity risks.

Investors in stock markets are often found to follow what others are doing rather than following their market analysis. For, they tend to believe that majority cannot go wrong. This kind of herd behavior is often found to cause ill-founded market rallies/sell-offs. Prevalence of herd-instinct among investors is often found to be the underlying reason for the emergence of asset bubbles in financial markets. The last paper of the issue, "The Impact of Herd Mentality and Pain of Regret Bias on Investment Decisions", examines if there exists herd mentality among investors and also the impact of demographic factors on the behavioral biases of investors. The authors, Priya Angle and Sasmita Giri, have found that the investors display herd mentality in their investment decisions. They have also found that demographics impact the herd mentality of investors. However, there is a limitation to the study: the sample is confined to a small region.

- Ranajee
Consulting Editor

Article   Price (₹)
A Comparative Analysis of Capital Asset Pricing Model and Arbitrage Pricing Theory in the Indian Stock Market Using Davidson-MacKinnon Equation
100
Decomposing Rating Migration Matrices from Market Prices: Sources of Nonlinearity and Resolve
100
Rainfall Forecasting Announcement and Commodity Spot Price Fluctuation: Evidence from Six Selected Food Commodities with Reference to Indian Commodity Market
100
The Impact of Herd Mentality and Pain of Regret Bias on Investment Decisions
100
Contents : (December '20)

A Comparative Analysis of Capital Asset Pricing Model and Arbitrage Pricing Theory in the Indian Stock Market Using Davidson-MacKinnon Equation
Shikha Menani

Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) and Arbitrage Pricing Theory (APT) are the two models that assess the risk-return relationship and help in the stock and/or portfolio evaluation. The two models, however, differ in the way factors are priced in the return-generating process. While the CAPM considers a single factor, that is beta, being the determinant of the cross-sectional differences in the asset pricing, APT considers various macroeconomic factors that determine the asset prices. The present study has used Davidson-MacKinnon equation to compare the two models using 221 securities listed on the Indian stock market, covering the period January 2000 to December 2018. The results favor the single-factor model, i.e., CAPM, wherein the additional factors propounded by APT had not improved the explanatory power of the risk-return relationship for the study period.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

Decomposing Rating Migration Matrices from Market Prices: Sources of Nonlinearity and Resolve
Brian Barnard

This study, a part of a larger work on decomposing rating migration matrices from market prices, investigates the matter of the associated optimization problem, in plain form, yielding multiple possible local solutions. The sources of nonlinearity and complexity of the optimization problem are outlined. This includes the rating category migration variance results of solutions, in terms of values and spacing, and within matrix rating category structures. Plain optimization problem decompositions struggle to surface, and correct both rating category migration variance values and spacing, and rating category matrix structures. Generally, full matrix decompositions require good initial solutions to yield good results. Matrix averaging and matrix sampling are considered. Matrix averaging is based on limited coefficient counts or sets-not using the full coefficient count, but rather grouping coefficients. Matrix sampling forms an approximation of the matrix, in a sense through parsimony. Matrix averaging represents simple(r) optimization problems, and offers easy solutions, with good results and information, but offers poor initial solutions for full matrix decomposition. Matrix sampling can offer good indications, and good initial solutions for full matrix decomposition. Full matrix decomposition from initial solutions sourced through matrix sampling offers good results. Overall, revisiting and re-examining the way that the optimization algorithm searches optimal solutions based on the initial solution provided, can further improve decomposition results.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

Rainfall Forecasting Announcement and Commodity Spot Price Fluctuation: Evidence from Six Selected Food Commodities with Reference to Indian Commodity Market
Mohd Merajuddin Inamdar, Susanta Datta and Vinayak Karande

The paper evaluates the impact of rainfall forecast announcement on six selected commodity spot price fluctuation with reference to Indian commodity market. Using daily spot price data from January 2, 2017 to December 13, 2017, four research questions have been addressed by considering two rainfall forecasting announcement dates, April 18, 2017 and June 6, 2017, by the Indian Meteorological Department, Government of India. By adopting dummy regression, Bai-Perron (2003) multiple structural break point tests and lagged regression, the empirical results suggest that rainfall forecasting announcement is a very temporary phenomenon and there is no strong evidence of fluctuations in return on commodity spot prices. This observation is also supported by ARIMA modeling, where it has been found that the return on spot price fluctuation behavior can be explained better with the help of lower order moving average models like MA1, MA2, etc. The results are statistically parsimonious because they are consistent with the real-life fact that agriculture product pricing is subject to the matter of seasonality which can persist for a short span of time, and this observation has been supported by the finding from lagged regression that lag 1 is significant at 1% level in maximum cases. The policy suggestions are that there is a need to introduce weather derivatives in Indian market to hedge risk due to weather variability and the meteorological department should improve its penetration of information among traders and farmers to achieve price efficiency.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

The Impact of Herd Mentality and Pain of Regret Bias on Investment Decisions
Priya Angle and Sasmita Giri

This paper examines how the herd mentality and regret bias of investors impact their investment decisions. Primary data was collected from employees, stock brokers, students and others who are either active investors in the stock market or following it regularly. The questionnaire is divided into two parts, consisting of demographical questions and technical questions on herd mentality and regret bias. Regression analysis and descriptive analysis were done on the data. The approach of this study is different as it uses situation-based questions and demographics to find out how their affect the investor's biases.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100