Dec'18
Focus
Antonio Gramsci, an Italian Marxist thinker, is credited with introducing the term �subaltern� to literary and critical theory. Gramsci uses the term in his notebook �Notes on Italian History,� which forms part of his Prison Notebooks, written between 1929 and 1935 when he was imprisoned by Italy�s Fascist regime. Though Gramsci uses the terms �subaltern� (classi subalterne), �subordinate� (classi subordinate), and �instrumental� (classi strumentali) interchangeably in the said work, the consensus is that the Gramscian subaltern refers to those groups in society that are of inferior rank, subjected to the hegemony of the ruling class. One of the founders of the Italian Communist Party, Gramsci employs the term to refer to the peasantry, the working class, and other such groups traditionally denied access to hegemonic power by the ruling elite�i.e., those that the Marxists would collectively designate �the proletariat.�
The term �subaltern� gained wider currency and newer significance in the early 1980s when it was adopted by the Subaltern Studies Group (SSG), a group of South Asian intellectuals interested in the postcolonial and postimperial societies, to refer to the populations that are politically, socially, and geographically outside the hegemonic power structure of the colonies, with a new class of colonialist elite and bourgeois-nationalist elite replacing the erstwhile colonial rulers in the pecking order.
Today, a subaltern is any person or group of inferior rank or station whether because of gender, sexual orientation, ethnicity, religion, race, or class. And the approach of the subaltern studies is essentially an antiessentialist one, where history is told �from below,� focusing more on the subaltern voices that challenge the majoritarian discourse and the silencing effect of domination. It is a case of not just the Empire but many Mini-Empires within writing back to the Centers of political power, challenging the alternative formulas for legitimation of neocolonialism. Subaltern studies then focuses on �history from below��the counter-hegemonic practice, social movement, resistance, and struggle against neocolonial forces that seek to privilege their dominant discourse as the normative one. In sum, the subaltern struggle and the politics of place is an evolving story of their ongoing quest for human equality, voice, agency, and representation.
However, as Gramsci (Selections from the Prison Notebooks of Antonio Gramsci, London: ElecBook, 1999, 206) informs, �the history of subaltern social groups is necessarily fragmented and episodic,� because of their tendency to submit, despite their efforts to break free of the entrenched system, to the authority of the ruling class, in the process limiting their access to and representation in the dominant discourse and social and cultural institutions. �There undoubtedly does exist a tendency,� continues Gramsci, �to unification in the historical activity of these groups, but this tendency is continually interrupted by the activity of the ruling groups� (206-207). Hence, it is necessary to study, Gramsci avers, the origins of disparate subaltern groups in preexisting social groups; their active or passive affiliation to the dominant political formations and their attempts to influence the programs of these formations in order to press claims of their own; the birth of new parties of the dominant groups intended to conserve the assent of the subaltern groups and maintain control over them; the formations which the subaltern groups themselves produce in order to press claims of a limited and partial character; those new formations which assert the autonomy of the subaltern groups, but within the old framework; and those formations which assert the integral autonomy.
�The subaltern classes, by definition,� contends Gramsci, �are not unified and cannot unite until they are able to become a �State�� (202). In other words, the subaltern groups cannot unite and present a unified front if they fail to establish organic relations with the political society (the realm of force, comprising the police, the army, the judiciary, and so on) and the civil society (the realm of consent, comprising the family, the education system, trade unions, and so on).
Incidentally, Indian author Arundhati Roy�s latest novel, The Ministry of Utmost Happiness�an engagement with the larger political and social history of India, especially with its margins�seeks to bring together and unify disparate subalterns on a counterhegemonic platform.
Rajeshwar Mittapalli discusses, in his paper, how the subalterns in Arundhati Roy�s abovementioned novel go on to create and expand �an alliance of utmost happiness� against the majoritarian attack and thus chart their own course from passivity to autonomy.
Shraddha Dhal delineates the plight of Shanta the Ayah in Bapsi Sidhwa�s Ice-Candy-Man, who as a helpless victim of communal oppression and patriarchal perversion symbolizes the fate of gendered subalterns.
Kabita Mondal and Joydeep Banerjee assert, with reference to Amruta Patil�s graphic novel Kari that features a lesbian protagonist, that graphic novel, with its dual medium of visual and verbal, has the same potential as other literary genres to induce empathy in us, the readers, and thus teach us values such as the importance of understanding those who are different from ourselves.
Eman Khalil Mukattash examines the different forms of �semiotic takes��namely, surrogate mothers, nature, surrogate fathers, sisterhood, storytelling, and motherhood�and the two protagonists� ability to retain connection with the World of the Mother in each case in Willa Cather�s novel My Antonia.
Saumya Bera, Soumyajyoti Banerjee, and Rajni Singh attempt to, using existentialism as an analytical tool, deconstruct and deexoticize, with reference to Gita Mehta�s Karma Cola, the orientalist metanarrative of the �self,� in the context of Orient-Occident encounter, with a view to highlighting the need for demythologizing the standardized norms of perception.
Devi Archana Mohanty and Sangeeta Mukherjee analyze Jhumpa Lahiri�s short story �Interpreter of Maladies� using face negotiation theory to illustrate that participants in social interaction are guided by their cultural assumptions and situational needs while negotiating their face needs and face concerns.
Ashima Shrawan discusses in detail the theory of vakrokti as propounded by Kuntaka (circa 950�1050 CE), a Sanskrit literary theorist, in his work Vakroktijivitam, highlighting how vakrokti that emanates from the creative faculty of the poet endows the common language with flair, salience, and consummate beauty.
G Alan discounts the conventional Eurocentric language learning methods and proposes a postmodern ethno-relative model of language learning that stresses on incorporating multiple skills, including life skills, in the learning process to fulfill the requirements of the learners as well as the corporate.
|
|||
Article | Price (₹) | ||
The Subaltern Saga Continues: Politics of Silence and Poetics of Articulation in Arundhati Roy�s The Ministry of Utmost Happiness |
100
|
||
The Ayah as a Subaltern in Bapsi Sidhwa�s Ice-Candy-Man |
100
|
||
Locating Amruta Patil�s Graphic Novel Kari Within the Silhouette of the Theory of Empathy |
100
|
||
Back to the Mother: Matrilineal Linkage in Willa Cather�s My Antonia |
100
|
||
Interrogating the Self: Demythologizing the Discourse of Nirvana in Gita Mehta�s Karma Cola |
100
|
||
Face Negotiation and Politeness in �Interpreter of Maladies� |
100
|
||
Kuntaka�s Theory of Vakrokti: The Language of Literature |
100
|
||
Learner Autonomy in the Postmodern Classroom: A Poststructural Study |
100
|
The Subaltern Saga Continues: Politics of Silence and Poetics of Articulation in Arundhati Roy�s The Ministry of Utmost Happiness
In more ways than one, Arundhati Roy�s latest novel The Ministry of Utmost Happiness continues the subaltern saga initiated in her debut novel The God of Small Things. Velutha, the titular �god of small things,� was permanently silenced for trespassing on the upper-caste social spaces and violating its moral codes. In the forty years� interregnum between the fictional times of the two novels, the religious and sexual minorities too have joined the dalits in experiencing discrimination and ill-treatment and are required to constantly contend with outmoded moral codes, caste-based discrimination, and majoritarian violence. The Ministry of Utmost Happiness offers a mind-numbing account of how almost all its major characters experience silence for reasons beyond their control�birth, sexual orientation, social/cultural impositions, and so on�but finally learn to break it in their own individual ways. In the process, they achieve a limited realization of their true selves and learn to manage the fear, hypocrisy, and negativity imposed on them. This paper charts their passage from passivity to autonomy and concludes that they offer, as a collective, a way out of the morass Indian society is now embroiled in.
The Ayah as a Subaltern in Bapsi Sidhwa�s Ice-Candy-Man
Bapsi Sidhwa has successfully carved a niche for herself in the realm of Asian women�s writings. Her empathy for her women characters reflects her sensitivity to the stifled voices and the unspoken plight of the subaltern, the marginal, and the subsidiaries. The characters have been described as shaped by prejudice born of religious inequality, cultural subjugation, and above all cataclysmic political upheavals like the Partition of India. Sidhwa, who wants a world free of patriarchy and hierarchy, obliges us to meet her women who can be heard and translated, but have been rendered mute in a space dominated by males. This paper studies, with reference to the novel Ice-Candy-Man, the infliction of sufferings on women and the formation of the subaltern identity thereby. It focuses on the character of the Ayah in the novel, who, as a victim of oppression, symbolizes the fate of the subaltern.
Locating Amruta Patil�s Graphic Novel Kari Within the Silhouette of the Theory of Empathy
Empathy being an interdisciplinary issue plays a significant role in art and aesthetics just like in psychology, philosophy, neuroscience, anthropology, and so on. Literature enhances the reader�s qualities, social or moral, exposing him to hundreds of virtues and values. Graphic novel employing the dual medium, visual and verbal, has great potential to explore empathic abilities; as is often said, pictures are more powerful than words. Suzanne Keen, in the context of discussing narrative empathy of literature, observed this minutely and explained that traditional or canonical literature has the power to enhance one�s finer feelings with the help of narrative empathy. According to contemporary neuroscience, the reader or observer shows empathy due to the activation of the mirror neurons in his brain. And the reason for the activation of mirror neurons is the visualization of actions and incidents in the context of visual art such as painting, movie, and graphic novel, and internal visualization in the context of a text using only the verbal mode. The reader may experience a vicarious aesthetic encounter with a canonical text as well as with a graphic novel. This paper makes an empirical study of Amruta Patil�s graphic novel Kari, situating it within the different theoretical frameworks of narrative empathy.
Back to the Mother: Matrilineal Linkage in Willa Cather�s My Antonia
The paper approaches the question of female identity in Willa Cather�s My Antonia from a psychoanalytic perspective based on opposing Jacques Lacan�s view of identity as a form of �masquerade� and Julia Kristeva�s view of identity as a form of �jouissance.� Though Antonia is a victim, she manages to establish herself as a desiring subject in the Symbolic.
Interrogating the Self: Demythologizing the Discourse of Nirvana in Gita Mehta�s Karma Cola
This is a study of demythologization of the concept of Nirvana (self-actualization) as elucidated in Gita Mehta�s Karma Cola. The study is an attempt to decanonize, delegitimize, deconstruct, and destabilize the metanarrative of the �Self,� functioning within an Orientalist discourse that forms the crux of the ideation, dissemination, and preservation of mythic structures of the Oriental, especially spiritual, tradition. Existentialism is employed as an analytical tool to illustrate the insincerity of the thesis of enlightenment and the angst ensuing from disenchantment at the failure of the quest for mystical panacea within Eastern religious ethics.
Face Negotiation and Politeness in �Interpreter of Maladies�
Politeness, a social interpersonal communicative behavior, is often associated with courtesy, solidarity, and friendliness. Face is considered to be an important aspect of politeness, and politeness arises due to effective face negotiation during interactions. It is assumed that people constantly negotiate their face needs to show politeness toward others. In intercultural contexts, the concern for face gains prominence. This paper focuses on the face negotiation process in intercultural discourse situations. Jhumpa Lahiri�s �Interpreter of Maladies� has been chosen for this purpose. The techniques chosen for analysis include face negotiation, face-enhancing, and face-threatening strategies, and the method preferred is face negotiation theory. The analysis reveals that while negotiating their face needs and showing their face concern to others, the participants are guided not only by their cultural assumptions but are also influenced by the situational needs.
Kuntaka�s Theory of Vakrokti: The Language of Literature
Literature is the most conscious use of language. It is a language within language and an art of language. It is a special kind of human discourse in which the writer tries to communicate his/her vision or ideas in a highly individualized medium by resorting to a particular and, in part, unique use of language. This unique use of language is a process in which the basic concept is transformed into an effective and meaningful message. It is the most delightful and perfect form of utterance that human word can reach. Indian thinkers have their own distinctive concept of the language of literature in which they fully appreciate the oblique elements which they call vakrokti. In the present paper, an attempt has been made to unfold how Kuntaka treats the language of literature as vakrokti, delineating its nature and different levels.
Learner Autonomy in the Postmodern Classroom: A Poststructural Study
The paper problematizes the existing pedagogical methods of teaching language in the conventional classroom by deconstructing the Eurocentric language teaching methods. It also proposes postmodern pedagogy and metacurriculum for the autonomous learners by challenging the limitations of the conventional curriculum. The paper also deconstructs the existing ethnocentric model of language learning by proposing an ethno-relative model of language learning.