June'20

The IUP Journal of English Studies

Focus

Welcome to the era of ?post-truth,? in which news and histories are faked, propaganda and disinformation are passed on as alternative facts, and emotional appeal is preferred to reasoning and evidence.

Used first, in 1992, by Serbian American playwright Steve Tesich, the term ?post-truth? gained popular currency in the run up to the 2016 US presidential election and the UK?s Brexit referendum in June the same year. The instant acceptance and popularity of the term worldwide won it recognition from the Oxford Dictionaries, which named it the ?Word of the Year? for 2016, defining the adjective as ?relating to or denoting circumstances in which objective facts are less influential in shaping public opinion than appeals to emotion and personal belief.?

The prefix ?post? in post-truth does not mean that we are ?past? truth; it just means the end or burial of objective facts by an avalanche of misinformation aimed at appealing to people?s emotions, making, in the process, truth unimportant and irrelevant. Significantly, Trump?who won the US presidential election in 2016 but lost the popular vote, and who has been dubbed the ?King of Whoppers? by FactCheck.org ?for the sheer number of his factually false claims, [and] also for his brazen refusals to admit error when proven wrong??with his daily outpouring of half-truths and self-dealing on his Twitter page, has emerged as the immediately recognizable face of the post-truth world, of its post-truth politics.

According to the ?Fact Checker? of The Washington Post, it took President Trump 827 days to reach his first 10,000 lies, but just 440 days to reach his second 10,000 lies. While that would put even Pinocchio to shame, the fact remains that as the exponents of post-truth politics continue to repeat their talking points, swamping facts with harmful lies and innuendos, it is bound to create confusion and uncertainty in the minds of people and derail any meaningful debate or discussion. The sheer act of trotting out untruths, distortions, and exaggerations as facts in such numbers and at such a scale in a world of instant messaging would sooner rather than later subvert the very idea of communication, social relationships, public institutions, and those who play fair.

Post-truth politics is problematic, for it is self-serving and can prove detrimental to public interests, as Trump?s initial claims about the covid-19 pandemic (that it would weaken ?when we get into April, in the warmer weather?that has a very negative effect on that, and that type of a virus?) have painfully demonstrated. Trump?s understanding of and claims about SARS-CoV-2 were not backed by any scientific evidence and naturally his unobjective response to the crisis is widely seen to have done more harm than good to the nation he leads.

Twitter, after maintaining a hands-off approach for years, has thankfully now begun to fact-check Trump?s messages, appending, in a few cases, warning or explanatory labels to his tweets, as Trump, more than any other politician, is seen taking advantage of Twitter?s reach and immediacy to effectively pass on concoctions as facts to his gullible audience. However, Trump is just a product and not the cause of the post-truth era. The issue of post-truth is bigger than any individual. While social media giants like Google and Facebook, besides Twitter, have initiated measures to stamp out fake news from their websites, they are too little, too late. The issue of fake news in the post-truth world cannot be left to the arbitrary policies and interventions of these organizations. Consider this: these three business behemoths are today monitoring billions of messages posted everyday on their websites and apps, deciding what people across the world can/cannot read or view. Ironically, they happen to be the distributors as well as the moderators of fake news, which gives these social media platforms immense power to influence and mold the course of political conversation and thus who gets to wield power. This is scary.

Imagine a whole generation of tech-savvy youngsters growing up in a post-truth world of fake news and deception. What kind of informed choices can they make? Then, what is the way out of this precarious situation that we find ourselves in? Where does literature stand vis-?-vis post-truth? How can literature help salvage the situation? Salman Rushdie has an answer.

In his write-up ?Truth, Lies, and Literature? in The New Yorker (May 31, 2018), Rushdie has this to say: ?We need to recognize that any society?s idea of truth is always the product of an argument, and we need to get better at winning that argument. Democracy is not polite. It?s often a shouting match in a public square. We need to be involved in the argument if we are to have any chance of winning it. And as far as writers are concerned, we need to rebuild our readers? belief in argument from factual evidence, and to do what fiction has always been good at doing?to construct, between the writer and the reader, an understanding about what is real. . . . When we read a book we like, or even love, we find ourselves in agreement with its portrait of human life. Yes, we say, this is how we are, this is what we do to one another, this is true. That, perhaps, is where literature can help most. We can make people agree, in this time of radical disagreement, on the truths of the great constant, which is human nature. Let?s start from there.?

As George Orwell puts it, in his essay ?Literature and Totalitarianism,? ?Literature . . . is built on the concept of intellectual honesty, or, if you like to put it that way, on Shakespeare?s maxim, ?To thine own self be true.??

Hence, it is incumbent on the writers, in these post-truth times, to be intellectually, historically, and textually honest and express what they really think and feel. It should be the endeavor of literature to prod people into thinking what kind of society they want to live in and should strive after.



-Venkatesan Iyengar
Consulting Editor

Article   Price (₹)
Post-Truth Era and the Problem of Scientific Objectivity: A Reading of Ian McEwan?s Solar
100
Gothicizing American History: Religion, Race, and Politics in Joyce Carol Oates? The Accursed
100
Textual Bodiliness in Ondaatje?s The English Patient
100
Religion and Spirituality in Indian English Fiction
100
Temporality of Migration: A Study of Past and Present Lives of Migrants in Narratives from India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh
100
Representation of Gendered Violence in the Bangladesh Liberation War of 1971
100
Feminist Utopian Consciousness vis-a-vis Dystopian Speculative Vision
100
Female Space, Subjugation, and Identity Crisis in Rama Mehta's Inside the Haveli and Manju Kapur's Difficult Daughters
100
Quest for Empowerment and Assimilation: Images of Diaspora in Bharati Mukherjee's Jasmine
100
The Real and the Absurd in Harold Pinter's The Dumb Waiter
100
An Examination of Form-Focused Instruction: Isolated Versus Integrated and Focus on Forms Versus Focus on Form
100
The Phenomenon of Projection: A Genre-Based Study
100
Articles

Post-Truth Era and the Problem of Scientific Objectivity: A Reading of Ian McEwan's Solar
Resmy Dominic and M Mary Jayanthi

The fast growing technology and the accelerated knowledge explosion that followed it have directly or indirectly created a corresponding post-truth era. An incredulity toward the accepted knowledge consequently gained momentum in every formal and informal gathering. As postmodernists suggest, the present age has become an age of hyperreality, mostly characterized by faking and simulations. Similarly, post-truth era directs one's attention toward the probable or possible truths than the ultimate truths. Thus, this era reflects a trend where lies become widely accepted truths. Among the established systems of knowledge, science remains highly objective and scientists claim this objectivity with the backing of evidence gathered through experiments. But even scientific objectivity is under scrutiny in the present scenario. Ian McEwan's Solar, with its sarcastic portrayal of the subjective elements which drive the objectivity of scientists and further invite disaster on the future of human race, stands as a fine example of the post-truth tendencies. Focusing on these aspects, this paper examines how the scientific claim of objectivity is contradicted by the post-truth phenomenon and how literature presents this conflict through Ian McEwan's Solar.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

Gothicizing American History: Religion, Race, and Politics in Joyce Carol Oates' The Accursed
Nilanjana Ghosal

Racist politics and white moral superiority are persistently parodied and subverted in Oates's recent Gothic novel, The Accursed. The novel turns back to early twentieth century Princeton, an elite society struggling under the "Crosswicks Curse," and reconsiders history through the Gothic lens to critique the discriminatory ideology of America's classic Religious Right. Appropriately, this paper isolates the recurring problematic of racism in the novel first to demonstrate how through the creation of the "other," racist politics and white moral superiority were rationalized by the powerful, and second to recognize how national leaders obsessed with ideas of purity lead double lives engendering a duality that emerges from their warped interpretations of Christianity. Further, by addressing the duplicity inherent in American history, religion, and its socialist/secularist discourses, this reading defines The Accursed as a postsecular reflection seeking to re-vision the nation's past.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

Textual Bodiliness in Ondaatje's The English Patient
Nasser Y Athamneh and Muttasim Alrawashdeh

This paper aims at eliciting the human and physical aspects of Michael Ondaatje's 1992 novel, The English Patient. It argues that the human and physical aspects of this novel are derived from its very signs, its author's textual existence or inclusion, its characters and their actions, and its readers' interaction with its text. The paper tries to show that the author, the text, and the reader are in a state of constant interaction and exchange of physical/bodily activities and traits/characteristics. It concludes that the writer, the text, and the readers of The English Patient are involved equally in reciprocal simulative bodiliness that forms a significant aspect of the processes of writing and reading works of fiction. Close textual reading/analysis is employed as the method of presentation in the paper.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

Religion and Spirituality in Indian English Fiction
Jagdish Batra

That the ancient Indian culture is intertwined with religion goes without saying. However, understood and practiced as a simultaneously fixed as also changeable dharma in India, this concept befuddles the Western mind and also the West-influenced Indian mind. This study analyzes the concept of dharma to identify its constituent and differentiating elements like beliefs, scriptures, ethics, rituals, and symbols, and traces in some major texts of Indian English Fiction, from the earliest days to contemporary times, the treatment of external religious practices, texts, gurus, myths, and finally the transcendent spiritual consciousness. What the study finds is that not much focus is found on the intricacies of dharma in Indian English Fiction, in which it is mostly the exotic that catches the author's eye. Moreover, whatever deeper we find is a reductive and oversimplified view of dharma, seen through the Western lens. However, the tide seems to be turning with some of the young generation writers seriously undertaking the journey of self-realization and making self-experience the basis of writing.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

Temporality of Migration: A Study of Past and Present Lives of Migrants in Narratives from India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh
Bibhudatta Dash

Often migrants are caught between spaces where they live negotiating between their past and present selves. A sense of nostalgia traps them from within, which gets reflected in comparative parameters through their interaction with the new place and culture, through changing frameworks of family and relations, and through varying levels of perceptions. As a social phenomenon, migration gets potent when seen through the perspectives of time, nostalgia, and memory. Temporality hence is closely connected to the understanding of the process of migration. This paper aims to analyze the conditions and situations that the migrants face when aspects of time and remembrance are brought together on a temporal scale of past and present from select migrant narratives of India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

Representation of Gendered Violence in the Bangladesh Liberation War of 1971
Sanjib Kr Biswas and Priyanka Tripathi

Post-1990s' internet boom and subsequent media intervention completely altered the face of representing crime investigation, medicine, science, and technology. Literary narratives, fictional and nonfictional, could also not refrain from this influence, and therefore, they too adapted themselves in a way that the narrative nonfiction too became fabricated under the supervision of the editors. An interesting but confusing event in the world history is the Bangladesh Liberation War of 1971, for it is represented in conflicting narratives of war crime and victimization. Linton (2010b) claims that over three million people were brutally killed and hundreds and thousands of women were raped by the allied forces of Pakistani army and pro-Pakistani Razakars during the nine-month-long freedom struggle. In 1992, Ibrahim (1994) in her book Aami Birangana Balchi (A War Heroine, I Speak) and Mookherjee (2015) in The Spectral Wound recount the stories of Biranganas (literally, brave heroines of the war). However, the counternarratives by Saikia (2004) and Bose (2011) argue that such generalization of Pakistani military being the only perpetrator in the 1971 war is futile as Bengali nationalists also raped non-Bengali Bihari women during and after the war. In the light of this paradoxical representation of gendered violence in the said war, the paper revisits these narratives and the related controversies to attest that truth is relative and also fabricated in narrative nonfiction.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

Feminist Utopian Consciousness vis-a-vis Dystopian Speculative Vision
Vandana Sharma

Though there is a slew of critiques on women's visions of utopia/dystopia as a systematic worldview (in which gender, body, sexuality, culture, environment, technology, psychology, and belief are entangled) that takes diverse generic forms, this paper aims to map out the shift from utopian vision to dystopian paradox, which demolishes old certainties in favor of a new, and sometimes, perhaps, a more disconcerting vision of a feminist future as portrayed in Manjula Padmanabhan's Escape. While there is a tremendous amount of significant research linking the recent trends in contemporary feminist theorizing about how and why events, practices, knowledge(s), and texts are forms of expression of patriarchal power relations, there are very few studies which enable some understanding of the transformative potential as well as the ideological blind spots of this utopianism. This paper aims to address these issues through simultaneously close and contextualized readings of Begum Rokeya Sakhawat Hossain's Sultana's Dream (1905) and Padmanabhan's Escape (2008).


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

Female Space, Subjugation, and Identity Crisis in Rama Mehta's Inside the Haveli and Manju Kapur's Difficult Daughters
Niraja Saraswat

Few institutions challenge more deeply our ethos of individual freedom and equality than that of Purdah and Marriage the separation of women from all men except their husbands and brothers, and sequestering them in women's compound of gendered mansions. Marriage is often seen as the identity symbol for women, and getting settled in husband's home is the only bliss that women are supposed to be content with. The present paper sheds light on two novels Rama Mehta's Inside the Haveli and Manju Kapur's Difficult Daughters to portray the subjugation and identity crisis of women. The paper problematizes the concepts of female space, subjugation, identity crisis, and liberation through the protagonists: Geeta in Inside the Haveli and Virmati in Difficult Daughters.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

Quest for Empowerment and Assimilation: Images of Diaspora in Bharati Mukherjee's Jasmine
Yeddu Vijaya Babu

In recent times, postcolonial diaspora writing is principally concerned with themes such as marginalization, resistance, racism, ethnicity, adaptability, and self-independence. In the novel Jasmine, Bharati Mukherjee showcases the problems of women, particularly those related to cross-cultural crisis and quest for identity. Themes such as expatriate sensibility, the unresolved dilemma of modern women, and immigrants' admiration for Americanness find expression in the novel. This paper explores expatriatehood as a metaphysical experience of exile and the manifestations of diaspora by probing the protagonist's search for identity and transformation in Jasmine.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

The Real and the Absurd in Harold Pinter's The Dumb Waiter
Zeeshan Ali

This paper analyzes the amalgamation of absurdism and realism in Harold Pinter's The Dumb Waiter. The Dumb Waiter is the last of three earliest plays by Pinter that possesses the traits of the Theatre of the Absurd. The play projects the life of two hired killers during one of their missions and is highly flavored with realistic essence, which is mostly in contradiction with the principles of the Theatre of the Absurd. But due to the amalgam of absurdism and realism in Pinter's oeuvre, finding the realistic streaks in his works is not a tough task. Behind the thick layer of absurdity in The Dumb Waiter, the real characters with internal fears depict the pathetic status of a powerless man in a menacing atmosphere. The characters' futile struggle to protect themselves from their powerful master is rendered realistically.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

An Examination of Form-Focused Instruction: Isolated Versus Integrated and Focus on Forms Versus Focus on Form
Amirreza Karami and Freddie A Bowles

This paper presents a summary of the most recent research-oriented studies with a focus on two of the most important categorizations of Form-Focused Instruction (FFI): isolated versus integrated. The theoretical differences between the two different types of FFI are provided and a brief summary of the most recent studies is reported. The paper finds that isolated versus integrated instruction is a necessary technique and needs to be applied to the teaching process at the appropriate time. In general, the findings indicate that the tendency toward implicit learning of grammar through using communicative forms of the language is improving and the final outcome of this approach shows improvement and progress in the learners' production and language development.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100

The Phenomenon of Projection: A Genre-Based Study
Kamal Hasan Ali Abohadi

This paper aims at exploring the projection relations in the genre of court decisions. Projection is considered an important resource for meaning making. According to Halliday (Halliday and Matthiessen 2014, 506), it is the second type of logico-semantic relations by which a clause can combine with another clause to form a clause complex. The first type is known as "expansion," which is a direct representation of a nonlinguistic experience. On the other hand, "projection" is regarded as a "representation of a (linguistic) representation." Thompson (1994, 2) observes that a projection relation is a metaphenomenon wherein language is used to construe language itself rather than construing the experiential metafunction (i.e., real-world experiences). This paper analyzes the construal of projection relations in six court judgments three pertaining to civil law and three to criminal law.


© 2020 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 100