Sep'19

The IUP Journal of English Studies

Focus

A draconian provision, Section 377 of the IPC, framed in 1861 during the colonial regime and had survived till the apex court dispensed with it, states: “Whoever voluntarily has carnal intercourse against the order of nature with any man, woman, or animal shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years and shall also be liable to fine.” And the provision goes on to explain that “penetration is sufficient to constitute the carnal intercourse necessary to the offence described in this section.” The term “against the order of nature” gave scope for misreading as any type of sexual act other than coitus, that is, the sexual act of procreation between a man and a woman, could be construed as “against the order of nature.” And the term “voluntarily” made it plain that even if the “unnatural” act was a consensual one between adults, it constituted a crime.

Section 377 had hung like Damocles’ sword over the LGBTQ (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer or Questioning one’s sexual identity) individuals in India for more than one-and-a-half centuries. Though there were not many reported instances of this penal provision being used in independent India to persecute LGBTQs, its mere existence had instilled fear, making it difficult for LGBTQs to come out. While a same-sex couple did not have to worry about this provision as long as what they did in their personal lives remained within four walls, the possibility that they might have to reveal the nature of their relationship on occasions, like at a hospital, gave scope for intimidation, harassment, and extortion by the police as well as unscrupulous elements.

Also, the very existence of such a vague provision in the law books often determines the way society views same-sex relationship. Hence, the Supreme Court’s verdict annulling Section 377 gives “the love that dare not speak its name” not only legal validity but also popular acceptance.

The Supreme Court’s September 2018 verdict capped years of protracted administrative and legal battles that began around 2006 when the National AIDS Control Organization (NACO) under the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare headed by Dr. Anbumani Ramadoss filed affidavits in the Delhi High Court— hearing then a public interest litigation (PIL) challenging the legality of Section 377 of the IPC—contending that decriminalizing same-sex relationship would help in better tracking and controlling the spread of HIV/AIDS. Interestingly, the Health Ministry’s plea was opposed by the Union Home Ministry headed by Shivraj Patil on “moral grounds.” Evincing a homophobic attitude that behooved religious fundamentalists, the Home Ministry submitted to the Delhi High Court that homosexuality is a “disease” and a “reflection of a perverse mind,” which forced the court to object to the Home Ministry’s unscientific stand on the issue.

In July 2009, the Delhi High Court nullified Section 377, holding that it violated the fundamental right to life and personal liberty and the right to equality as guaranteed in the Constitution. However, this momentous verdict was overturned by a two-judge Supreme Court bench in December 2013. In August 2017, a nine-judge constitution bench of the Supreme Court expressed its disapproval of the 2013 judgment and gave a broad hint that it would soon decriminalize homosexuality. In the words of the bench: “The purpose of elevating certain rights to the stature of guaranteed fundamental rights is to insulate their exercise from the disdain of majorities, whether legislative or popular. The guarantee of constitutional rights does not depend upon their exercise being favorably regarded by majoritarian opinion. . . . Discrete and insular minorities face grave dangers of discrimination for the simple reason that their views, beliefs, or way of life does not accord with the ‘mainstream.’ Yet in a democratic Constitution founded on the rule of law, their rights are as sacred as those conferred on other citizens to protect their freedoms and liberties.”

With the opinion of all major political parties of India gradually veering round to doing away with the archaic Section 377, the final verdict of the five-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court on the contentious issue did come in September 2018: “Sexual orientation is immutable, since it is an innate feature of one’s identity, and cannot be changed at will. The choice of LGBTQ persons to enter into intimate sexual relations with persons of the same sex is an exercise of their personal choice, and an expression of their autonomy and self-determination. Section 377 insofar as it criminalizes voluntary sexual relations between LGBTQ persons of the same sex in private, discriminates against them on the basis of their ‘sexual orientation’ which is violative of their fundamental rights guaranteed by Articles 14, 19, and 21 of the Constitution.”

Objecting to the way Section 377 sought to stigmatize LGBTQ individuals, the Supreme Court observed, “If a single, homogenous morality is carved out for a society, it will undoubtedly have the effect of hegemonizing or ‘othering’ the morality of minorities,” and called on the government to “undertake programs of education and awareness to promote and enhance the full enjoyment of all human rights by all persons, irrespective of sexual orientation or gender identity.”

Talking of education and awareness, literature, as a dominant branch of art, has played a stellar role in challenging the majoritarian social, cultural, and epistemological narratives and championing the LGBTQ cause. For instance, Indian Literature boasts writings spanning over more than two thousand years which demonstrate that same-sex love has flourished, evolved, and been embraced in various forms in India since ancient times (for more on this, see Same-Sex Love in India: A Literary History, edited by Ruth Vanita and Saleem Kidwai, New Delhi: Penguin Books, 2008).

In the field of literary theory and criticism, Queer Studies, also known as Sexual Diversity Studies, has emerged as an academic discipline focusing on issues relating to human sexuality, gender identity, sexual orientation, and sexual nonconformity, with emphasis on LGBTQ issues. Though queer studies—as Donald E Hall and Annamarie Jagose point out in their “Introduction” to The Routledge Queer Studies Reader (London: Routledge, 2013)—is prominently organized around sexuality, it does not seek to separate sexuality from other axes of social difference such as race, ethnicity, class, gender, and nationality and attends to the ways in which various categories of difference inflect and transform each other. In short, what women’s studies does for gender, queer studies does for sexuality.

In this issue, Joydeep Bhattacharyya explores Indian theatre’s trajectory of development in negotiating same-sex relationship onstage with reference to selected plays by Vijay Tendulkar and Mahesh Dattani; Avijit Pramanik and Arindam Modak examine the metafictional traits in Paul Auster’s novel Travels in the Scriptorium; Virender Pal and Divyajyoti Singh analyze the “re-storying” aspect of Louise Erdrich’s The Game of Silence; Nakul Kundra shows how in Raja Rao’s Kanthapura religious elements and myths are revised for accomplishing political ends; Madhulika Panda studies Chitra Banerjee Divakaruni’s reconstruction of the Mahabharata from Draupadi’s perspective in The Palace of Illusions; C V Padmaja and S Sushma Raj discuss, with reference to the works of Rohinton Mistry and Shyam Selvadurai, how Canada’s multiculturalism has encouraged diasporic writers to retain their cultural identities; Rajni Singh and Archana Verma trace the gothic elements in the early poems of T S Eliot; Geetha V Sharma and Jayagowri Shivakumar demonstrate the efficacy of projected-based learning for improving Business Management students’ communication skills; and Ali Derakhshan, Mahnaz Saeidi, and Fatemeh Beheshti present the findings of their study on the relationship between students’ second language learning and language teachers’ conceptions of intelligence, care, feedback, and students’ stroke.

-Venkatesan Iyengar
Consulting Editor

0 Items In Your Cart
CheckOut
Article   Price (₹) Buy
Vijay Tendulkar’s A Friend’s Story and Mahesh Dattani’s Seven Steps Around the Fire and On a Muggy Night in Mumbai: Reperforming Gender
50
Characters in Pursuit of the Author for Revenge: Reading Paul Auster’s Travels in the Scriptorium as a Metafictional Fête
50
“Re-Storying” to Reverse the Game of Silence: Louise Erdrich’s Narrative Rescue from Reductive Western Discourses
50
Gandhian Nationalism in the Garb of Religion and Dharma: A Study of Raja Rao’s Kanthapura
50
Chitra Banerjee Divakaruni’s The Palace of Illusions: Mythology Reconstructed
50
Multicultural Canada and Diasporic Writers: Rohinton Mistry and Shyam Selvadurai
50
Gothic Production in the Early Poems of T S Eliot
50
Project Assignment as an Effective Method to Enhance the Communication Skills of Business Management Students
50
The Interplay Between Iranian EFL Teachers’ Conceptions of Intelligence, Care, Feedback, and Students’ Stroke
50
     
Articles

Vijay Tendulkar’s A Friend’s Story and Mahesh Dattani’s Seven Steps Around the Fire and On a Muggy Night in Mumbai: Reperforming Gender
Joydeep Bhattacharyya

The precolonial and colonial discourses on/of gender have come to be reviewed in the aftermath of India’s Independence in 1947. The spirit of rethinking the “given,” originated mostly under the alien/ colonial influences, creates a postcolonial situation that espouses a nationalistic consolidation on the one hand and looks into the alternative discourses marginalized by such consolidation on the other. As a result, different lost or marginal voices have come to the fore. Indian theatre, after the independence, lends a voice to these unacknowledged zones of silence. Plays have begun to question sexuality and gender, redefining not only the issues themselves but also the thematic purview of Indian theatre and the audience reception. In this context, the present paper seeks to read three plays: Vijay Tendulkar’s A Friend’s Story and Mahesh Dattani’s Seven Steps Around the Fire and On a Muggy Night in Mumbai. The paper examines how the plays challenge the conventional sex-roles through transgender identities and same-sex relations in a heterosexist society and how they trace the evolution of post-independence Indian theatre to be able to deal openly with taboo topics such as alternative sexuality.


© 2019 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 50

Characters in Pursuit of the Author for Revenge: Reading Paul Auster’s Travels in the Scriptorium as a Metafictional Fête
Avijit Pramanik and Arindam Modak

The term “metafiction” has stemmed forth varied tendentious criticisms and problematically denied all sorts of arduous efforts to confine it to any specific straightjacketed definition. While literally the prefix “meta” means “beyond,” making metafiction a literary offshoot which is “beyond fiction,” critics have been divided on the true nature of metafiction. Despite the multifarious interpretations of metafiction by various critics, we can attempt to figure out a few characteristics which include foregrounding the fictionality of fiction and reality, laying bare the writing technique, presentation of the paradoxical status of author-power, intertextuality, authorial intrusion and interaction with fictional characters, direct address to the readers, and projection of language as an arbitrary system. This paper seeks to locate the classic metafictional traits in Paul Auster ’s much-celebrated novel Travels in the Scriptorium and discern the answer to the question posed by the novel toward its ontological existence.


© 2019 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 50

“Re-Storying” to Reverse the Game of Silence: Louise Erdrich’s Narrative Rescue from Reductive Western Discourses
Virender Pal and Divyajyoti Singh

Development of Native Literatures is one of the most important developments of the twentieth century. The literature written by the Natives not only tries to resuscitate their culture which had been under attack for many centuries by the colonial powers, but it is also an attempt to shatter the stereotypes that have shown tremendous resilience in popular culture and literature. The current paper is a study of Native American writer Louise Erdrich’s novel The Game of Silence. The novel gives the readers a peep into the lifestyle of the Native Americans. In the course of showing the readers the lifestyle of Ojibwe people, Erdrich shows that the Natives were not barbarians or cannibals as shown by the colonial narratives, rather they cultivated and nurtured a culture that made excellent use of local conditions and environment. The novel also discusses the religious beliefs of the Natives and makes clear that the religion of the Indians was not a superstition as described by the missionaries and the colonial writers. The Natives in the novel appear to be sagacious, kindhearted, and morally upright. Erdrich shows that the Indians were inherently civilized. For them, civilizational etiquette did not lie in outer appearance; rather it was a part of their daily routine and an integral part of their existence.


© 2019 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 50

Gandhian Nationalism in the Garb of Religion and Dharma: A Study of Raja Rao’s Kanthapura
Nakul Kundra

Raja Rao’s Kanthapura, crafted in the style of Indian Puranas, abounds in religious and Dharmic elements. It depicts the discourse of Gandhian nationalism which has donned the garb of sacredness to stir and gratify the Indian religious sensibility. Myths are revised to fulfill political motives. Gandhi is portrayed as an incarnation of Shiva, who is on the mission to set free Brahma’s “beloved daughter from the enforced slavery.” Besides, the novel is wreathed in Dharma as law on the cosmic plane, as duty on the social plane, as virtue on the moral plane, and as religion on the spiritual plane.


© 2018 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 50

Chitra Banerjee Divakaruni’s The Palace of Illusions: Mythology Reconstructed
Madhulika Panda

The Palace of Illusions is one of Chitra Banerjee Divakaruni’s acclaimed novels that portrays Draupadi as a very strong and powerful character and retells the Mahabharata from her perspective. Tracing Panchaali’s life—from her fiery birth and lonely childhood, through her complicated relation with the enigmatic Krishna, to marriage, motherhood, and most relevantly her secret affection for Karna, her husbands’ deadliest foe—it is a deeply moving human story about a woman born into a man’s world. The paper studies Divakaruni’s dexterous portrayal of one of the strongest mythological heroines and her focus on reconstructing the grand epic from Draupadi’s perspective.


© 2019 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 50

Multicultural Canada and Diasporic Writers: Rohinton Mistry and Shyam Selvadurai
C V Padmaja and S Sushma Raj

Canada, a global community home for many people of different races and cultures, embraces all cultures—cultural diversity being one of the country’s most important national characteristics. All ethnocultural groups have official sanction to identify themselves with the culture of their choice and yet retain access to social and economic equality. Irrespective of race or ethnicity, the individuals in a multicultural society are entitled to equal treatment, protection from racial discrimination, equality of opportunity, and the right to remain culturally different. This proved an advantage to a diasporic writer operating within Canadian multiculturalism. The right to retain one’s culture has made many of the diasporic writers go back to their mother country in the choice of themes. The paper discusses how Rohinton Mistry and Shyam Selvadurai, the two South Asian diasporic writers of Indian and Sri Lankan origin, too have gone back to India and Sri Lanka respectively in fictionalizing their lived experiences set in their countries of origin.


© 2019 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 50

Gothic Production in the Early Poems of T S Eliot
Rajni Singh and Archana Verma

There is something dangerous in T S Eliot’s poetry which is explosive, iconoclastic, violent, injurious, scary, and darkly optimistic, or one may even call it implicitly gothic. The dark elements in his poetry owe largely to the milieu, yet it moves from frame to frame, poem to poem, which perhaps showcases that there is something more to this panorama of the dreary that might have resulted out of his fascination for the past. In his creative works, the past, which appears in allusive form, is cherished as a container of the now lost ontological balance of being. The past in the poet has been analyzed from the vantage point of the writer’s urge for a tradition. But in this paper, an attempt has been made to demonstrate his use of memory and his production of the gothic in his early poems. Also, the paper intends to explicate how Eliot’s ghostly world that conjures up from his memory provides a useful lens for understanding the ways in which he represented the fears and anxieties of his time.


© 2019 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 50

Project Assignment as an Effective Method to Enhance the Communication Skills of Business Management Students
Geetha V Sharma and Jayagowri Shivakumar

The aim of this paper is to examine how project-based learning can help Business Management students develop their communication skills. A cross-disciplinary project designed for the third-semester students of a business school in Bengaluru (Karnataka, India) was assigned to five student teams. Based on the outcomes of the project, it is concluded that project-based learning is an effective way to make students become autonomous learners and develop communication skills.


© 2019 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 50

The Interplay Between Iranian EFL Teachers’ Conceptions of Intelligence, Care, Feedback, and Students’ Stroke
Ali Derakhshan, Mahnaz Saeidi, and Fatemeh Beheshti

Language learning and language teaching are complicated processes which involve myriad factors such as intelligence, care, feedback, and stroke, grounded in Self-determination Theory (SDT) and Transactional Theory (TA), which may facilitate or hinder language learning and language teaching processes. This study contends that the four effective psychological factors, namely, language teachers’ conceptions of intelligence, care, feedback, and students’ stroke can be used as lenses to find out the association between and among teachers and students. The participants in the study comprised two hundred female students and thirty English language teachers. Four instruments were administered (one for teachers and three for students): Language Teachers’ Conceptions of Intelligence Scale (LTCI-S); Teacher Care Scale (TC-S); Language Teacher Feedback Scale (LTF-S); and Student Stroke Scale (SS-S). The results of Pearson product-moment correlation coefficient revealed that there was no statistically significant correlation between language teachers’ conceptions of intelligence and teacher care. However, there were statistically significant relationships across language teachers’ conceptions of intelligence, students’ stroke, and teacher feedback. The results of the regression model revealed that language teachers’ conceptions of intelligence cannot be predicted based on teacher care, students’ stroke, and teacher feedback.


© 2019 IUP. All Rights Reserved.

Article Price : ? 50