Corporate
governance has become a very important business issue in the
last decade. Many of corporate governance mechanisms like
`Audit Committee' have gained prominence in this period. Besides,
new regulatory norms legislations were also introduced. On
the other hand, organizations like OECD are also coming out
with corporate governance guidelines and trying to promote
voluntary corporate governance practices which are universally
accepted. In the first paper, "Global Governance Practice:
The Impact of Measures Taken to Restore Trust in Corporate
Governance Practice Internationally", Rolph N S Balgobin
analyzes the effectiveness of these measures through a literature
survey. His study points out that management research in the
field of corporate governance also increased sharply during
this period. It also highlights the theoretical underpinnings
in the corporate governance developments. The analysis concludes
that though the legislative changes indicate some positive
changes in improving the corporate governance practices, they
still have a long way to go. Similarly, the study suggests
that bringing uniformity in corporate governance practices
across the countries will also take more time.
New
regulatory developments in corporate governance systems greatly
affected the financial institutions, as they were already
tightly regulated by the central banks of the concerned countries.
In the second paper, "Banking Sector Governance: Lessons
from Hong Kong Listed BanksA Three-Year Perspective",
Lisa Barnes studies the changes in the governance structure
of the 12 listed banking entities in Hong Kong. Using a case
study approach, the paper discusses the changes in the important
corporate governance structures of the banks over a period
of three years (2004-06). It also talks about the corporate
governance mechanisms, such as Chairman-CEO duality, changes
in the percentage of independent directors in the board and
qualifications of the directors. The results indicate that
the corporate governance practices of the listed firms under
study have improved in the last three years in line with the
expectations of regulators who want to maintain Hong Kong's
status as a financial hub.
Most of the corporate governance mechanisms developed in Anglo-American
countries focus on shareholder protection rather than stakeholder
protection. But the relationship model countries have also
started adopting those mechanisms in recent years. In the
third paper, "Family Firms' Performance and Agency Theory:
What's Going on in the Italian Market?", Stefano Caselli,
Alberta Di Giuli and Stefano Gatti discuss the effect of control
structures prescribed by agency theory on the performance
of family controlled firms of Italy. The agency theory suggests
that the performance of the firm depends on how far the interests
of the managers (agents) align with that of the investors
(principals). It is possible to reduce the agency cost by
increasing the shareholdings of the insiders/managers or blockholders
or foreign investors. The paper suggests that such agency
theory measures have become redundant in the Italian firms
which are managed by the founders. It is because of the control
exercised by the founder is good enough to reduce the agency
costs and there is no need for additional measures. On the
other hand, in the non-founder family firms, i.e., the firms
where the successors of the founders manage the firms, the
above-mentioned measures are effective in improving some of
the performance parameters.
Audit
Committee is one of most important corporate governance mechanisms
of the Anglo-American model. In the last paper, "Audit
Committee Support and Auditor Independence", Zulkarnain
Bin Muhamad Sori, Shamsher Mohamad, and Siti Shaharatulfazzah
Mohd. Saad highlight on the relationship between the characteristics
of Audit Committee and independence of the external auditors.
The paper uses an empirical approach to study the relationship
between auditor independence and audit committee parameters
such as number of meetings of audit committee; details given
in the audit committee report in the annual report; roles
to approve and review audit fee; and composition of audit
board in Malaysia. The results suggest that auditor independence
is positively associated with the mentioned parameters, which
in turn means that audit committee plays a vital role in ensuring
independence of the external auditor in Malaysian firms.
--
S Subramanian
Consulting
Editor
|