This issue includes
topics ranging from supply chain relationship in automobile
makers with complexity of conglomerates, usage of web-based
strategic management software for teaching business students,
opportunity to target bottom of the pyramid market for
cigarette companies, a quest to create a learning organization
through convergence of ideas and paradigms, and a study
on strategic sourcing, creating a marquee for business
strategy. This issue is an attempt to bring out some strategic
perspectives from different functions that are modern
and deviate from the traditional management approaches
for business.
The
first paper, "An Investigation of the Kaisha:
A (Strategic) Study in Partner Management", by Carolan
McLarney, Ed Chung and Sheila A Randolph, is built on
case study-based research on buyer-supplier relationships
and procurement operations of a Japanese automobile manufacturing
firm's American subsidiary. Kaisha in Japan refers
to a `large company'. The Japanese buyer-supplier relationships
based on "keiretsu" (which refers to
a uniquely Japanese form of corporate organization that
works on an intimate partnership between government and
businesses) seem to have translated into the automobile
company's American operations, which reconfigured the
structure and relationships to compete more effectively
on a global scale. This paper examines different aspects
of the keiretsu supplier relationship model, the
arms-length model and the cooperative buyer-supplier partnering
models and how each is utilized within the Kaisha's
procurement operation. The research uses primary data,
in the form of survey and interviews of Kaisha
suppliers, and secondary data through various published
articles and reports. The paper also highlights the fact
that in the absence of a clear strategic supplier management
program, the Kaisha could not achieve a sustainable
base for competitive advantage in terms of cost, quality
and product delivery.
The
second paper, "International Business Strategy: An
Innovative Teaching and Learning Approach", by Basil
Janavaras, Emanuel Gomes, Punyadip Cheema and Suresh George,
confirms the expected benefit of a management consulting
software, a web-based strategic management tool called
the Global Marketing Management System Online (GMMSO)
as a learning tool for learners and practitioners that
can enhance critical thinking, decision making and business
strategy research skills. One of the most modern and pressing
challenges for international business faculty is to port
the real world into the classroom training environment.
The consulting software is shown to hold the answer by
providing a real and simulated platform that makes the
users to perform analyses regarding the firm's situation,
position in market, offerings, competition from a strategic
perspective to develop an online business plan that has
international scope. The purpose of this research is to
share pedagogical experiences of the software and student's
learning feedback. The finding establishes the GMMSO software
as a potential pedagogical tool in business strategy learning
that furthers the project-based learning model. The research
goes on to claim that "the GMMSO, unlike the commercially
available simulation games on strategy, is a real management
tool that provides a comprehensive, systematic and integrative
strategic planning process design to guide students through
the corporate decision making process."
The
third paper, "A Strategic Study on the Potential
Entry of Cigarette Companies' into the Indian Bidi
Industry", by Mukesh Taneja and R Patnaik, highlights
the potential opportunity for cigarette companies to explore
a huge untapped market in India albeit with some
structural, environmental and competitive challenges.
The study is based on the premise that the Indian tobacco
industry, though somewhat organized, is losing a strong
opportunity in a cost-sensitive market segmentthe `bidi'
segment, which is primarily unorganized and thus enjoys
cost advantages in the form of no taxes or duties. The
research provides a base for Indian cigarette companies
to enter the `bidi' market through a viability
study, benefits and pitfalls, and brings in experiences
from the international tobacco industry. The research
uses the qualitative approach of event-history analysis
that involves systematic identification of critical events
in the longitudinal development of the industry. The findings
suggest `bidi' market to be a large market (considerable
size), with high scope for product extension and social
responsibility towards poor `bidi' workers. The
research also highlights the possible competitive reactions
of the existing players (politicians, lobbyists and worker's
unions) in the `bidi' industry.
The
fourth paper, "Organizational Learning: Crafting
a Strategic Framework", by Feza Tabassum Azmi, draws
upon various literary works and paradigms on learning
organization to propose a strategic framework for organizational
learning with people-strategy matrix and learning prerequisites.
The modern organizational need towards constant revitalization
in learning has now become a necessary base for competitive
advantage, as a result of which creation of a learning
organization seems to be the only answer. The research
starts with a review of dominant organization learning
thoughts across different era, introduces the learning
iceberg concept that shows some laddering issues in creating
a strategic framework, and then goes on to establish a
people-strategy matrix for a clearer comprehension of
a learning strategy. Finally, the paper discusses some
learning prerequisites, including cultural and legacy
issues where internalization of transformational learning
takes time and can be built on iterative small moves rather
than large ones.
The
fifth paper, "Strategic Sourcing: Need for a Disciplined
Approach", by S N Mookherjee, is a study on organizational
sourcing of resources that creates efficient value chains,
which in turn is instrumental in building competitive
advantage. Sourcing has gone beyond the functional activity
of supply chain and means much more strategically across
the value chain, in the modern global scenario. The feature
suggests that firms desiring flexible and resilient value
chains need to look at the sourcing of each activity of
the value chain. This paper outlines outsourcing that
has become strategic in nature, with core functions such
as design, manufacturing, human resource, research and
development, marketing, and logistics, which are moved
offshore to get the best cost/value for that function.
It argues how strategic sourcing helps business to create
more efficient value chains, process improvements, and
function improvements, to create a superior competitive
position in the market.
-
Rajnandan Patnaik
Consulting
Editor